Wyoming Pastry Shop

Ordered my daughter cake from here after being told how good this bakery was. I'll say the girl who took my cake order when I came in to place it was very personable and courteous, customer service from her was 100. I also had gotten some donuts, cupcakes, and cookies the day I placed the order. Didn't care for the carrot cake cupcake. The coconut donut was pretty good. Their smiley face cookie reminded me of a healthier version of Busken's. My kids ate the cupcakes and said they liked them. The birthday ca

Gorgeous cookies and holiday treats. The best cake ever. My little grandson's 1st birthday was a hit because of his smash cake and cookies. So yummy. Such a quaint little place to have treats and donuts. Super friendly staff and very pleasant atmosphere.

The condescending rudeness of the woman working left a really sour taste rather than what I went in for. I anticipated a sweet experience like I?ve had every time I?ve stopped in when in town. I hope the cake I purchased for my family is better than her attitude and sincerely hope this isn?t the norm for this Wyoming icon. In fairness there was a very nice smiling young lady who tried to help and without her we would have had a horrible experience.

I have visited the pastry shop here and there for almost 20 years since my mom moved us out this way. They have always had great pastries and great service. Here lately I have been closely watching their Facebook story and have been seeing the cake slices they have for sale. I have seen a few that I wanted to get but just didn?t make it to get a slice. On Thursday 6/20/24, they posted yellow cake with cotton candy buttercream. I knew I needed to get it. After I picked up my son I called to see if they had a

Previously had left 5 star. Not today. Cookie was not with signage. She said it had royal icing. So? Got outside, bill was $17 which seemed high,, but the damn cookie was $7 frickin dollars! What was the red icing, actually 14k gold? So I thought, well is it a moist cookie with delicious icing?!?! Got home, one bite, most stale worthless cookie ever. BUYER BEWARE. Lost our business. I should have been told it was $7.00 or at least a sign on the tray. I NEVER in my life have bought a SEVEN DOLLAR cookie. Wor

The Wyoming Pastry Shop is amazing!!! I order all of our cakes for special occasions from them, and they are incredible every time. They just did a cake and a little smash cupcake for my daughter?s first birthday. The staff was so sweet when I placed my order. The cakes turned out so beautifully - even better than I pictured. They really went above and beyond. And of course both were delicious as always!! This pastry shop is so special, and we are so lucky to have it in our community.

Her cake was beautiful. The cupcakes tasted great as always

Just stopped in as we saw it driving by and the woman who helped us was so sweet and the place is adorable and let me tell you the pastry's were DELICIOUS!!! We will be back for sure!

I ordered my baby?s birthday cake the actual cake was good but I was very disappointed the art work was very sloppy. What I asked for versus what I got. We spent over two hundred dollars .??

Everything is made with love and tastes like it. Prices are crazy low (7$ for a whole coffee cake), they could be charging a lot more. Super friendly staff. Sells out early, which is the baking world means ur doing something right.

Good selection and everything seemed really fresh. I think we grabbed 4 donuts, 4 cookies, and a pastry which I can?t seem to recall the name and it was under $12. Would?ve grabbed more, but this place gets busy quick.

I placed an order several weeks ago for my sons 1st birthday who passed away at six days old last year. My wife and I went in yesterday to pick up the cake and it was absolutely beautiful. However, I went to pay for it and they said it was on them that I didn?t have to pay for the cake. Said they wanted to make the cake in honor and remembrance of our son. Also a worker there, Alisa Haynes made our son a sweet birthday card to go along with the cake, she was so caring. Thank you so much Wyoming Pastry Shop,

Originally had four stars just because I liked the place and Google asked me to review it before I'd even tried the pastries. Brought the pastries home and everybody loved them! Should have been five stars all along.

My husband's grandparents got their wedding cake here in 1963! We wanted to carry on the tradition and the cake was fabulous!

I?ve going to fufu bakeries in the past where they charge an ungodly amount for 1 doughnut. This place is nothing like that, the doughnuts were fresh and the staff was kind. All at an affordable price point. I love pastries and sweet treats. Its nice to find an affordable bakery that taste great.

Donuts were squished in a bag. When I got home icing was on tissue paper placed between donuts and off the donut itself. I guess back to Graeters where they use a box and no tissue paper on top. And this was no young person behind the counter doing it. I made a 50 minute car trip to receive these donuts. per friend recommendation, where I've had other tasty goods of yours in the past. I won't be back. Keep yur little pastry shop.

A stunning and delicious birthday cake. Super nice people. Great cookies and donuts. I love this shop!

Went in to get a birthday cake made for my fianc? .The two women just sat at the table and didn?t even acknowledge me

Amazing pastries and baked goods plus helpful and friendly employees!

I order a birthday cake for my son's 40th, which is a milestone had some family and friends coming over later to celebrate, but when I went to pick the cake up it was never made even though I paid half down even talked to the decorater Alyse. I've order cakes here before. All I got was I'm so sorry, would love to hear someone say we can make it right by making you another cake. And by the way I had my son's picture on the cake.

First time there today and the wonderful smell hit me as soon as I pulled up outside. We got a few cookies, donuts, and cupcakes and everything was delicious and tasted incredibly fresh. Looking forward to trying more items in the future. Staff was super friendly as well. I?m always looking for great bakeries and this one will definitely become part of my morning routine from now on.

Stopped in this morning to grab a couple dozen donuts for my husband's workplace. The service was amazing. I unfortunately did not get the name of the lady who assisted me, but she was so kind and helpful. Not to mention the donuts were a huge hit with the guys at the shop!! A little sweet treat on a Friday morning I think makes the day go a little better than usual. Thank you so much for the delicious treats and wonderful service!! Easy street parking made it an in and out trip. Even though it was around 8

Family has used this bakery for decades---but recently I have been using them for office celebrations. I have had SO many people ask me where the cake is from because it's so good. Will be using them again for future office dessert needs.

The cake we received from this establishment was truly outstanding, surpassing our expectations in flavor and excellence. Highly recommended.

I've never been to the store physically but I met someone who works for them. I asked her about the shirt she was wearing which was her work shirt for this bakery. A few days later she brought me some pastries to try and it was so kind and thoughtful. You should definitely stop by and support these kind people.

I ordered two cakes at the same time, a cherry cheesecake for a dinner party and a birthday cake for a gathering the following day. Robin was very helpful with helping me make my selections and both of these cakes were excellent. The cheesecake was light and full of flavor and the cherries were fresh and delicious. The birthday cake was a yellow cake with chocolate icing in the middle and an incredible butter cream icing on the outside. It not only tasted great but was beautifully decorated. Several

I got my cake on Saturday and it was scrumptious. Will definitely return. Thanks Wyoming Bakery. You did not disappoint

When I was doing my wedding cake tastings, I explained that my husband and I have pretty opposite schedules, so limited availability. They offered to give us our cake tasting to go. I mentioned a cake my husband really liked and they even made a little cake with that flavor just for us. I love how accommodating they are. If their customer service isn?t enough, they have the best donuts!

Wanted to try a new pastry shop and was not disappointed. We tried a few donuts, some pastries and had a coffee. The cream puff was excellent, perfect shoe pastry with a nice tempered chocolate top and light airy cream inside. I had to have a kettle Danish, the dough was nicely layered, crispy, and just enough icing to give a perfect sweetness. We will definitely return.

I picked up an ordered cake at 7:30am. I ordered a Dinner cake ( No Decorations). When I picked it up I noticed chocolate shavings on top which I didn't want. I wanted a plan chocolate cake. The young lady said this is the way the cake comes. The cake was ice cold. Hum - I didn't expect that. We needed to cut and serve the cake at 10:00. We tried to heat the cake in a microwave. But, the center was still very cold. I should have picked a cake up from Kroger's. I have ordered this cake a few times with early

Best donuts I?ve ever had hands down. I?ve been coming here for years and you won?t find better donuts anywhere. One thing I will say is that there have been multiple times where I have driven down there at a time that they are usually open and they have been closed for a special occasion so I would definitely call or just check online ahead of time before driving down. Other than that, second to none pastries, great service, great bakery all around.

Excellent people. Great goodies. They made ALL of my birthday cakes as a child. And many of my son's also. Always something delicious and sometimes unique in store for you here. Always has fresh water outside for our 4 legged babies

Chocolate Torte, Gingerbread cookie

I'm not usually a cake person, but a few weeks ago a coworker brought in the yellow cake with chocolate frosting from the Wyoming Pastry Shop and I LOVED it. I have already bought another cake to show my wife how good this place is, and she loved it too. I know where all my birthday and other celebration cakes are coming from in the future!

Unbelievably disappointed with the cookie order. Cannot believe how much I was charged for such generic decorating. I had such high hopes with all the great reviews. Now here I am having to spend more time & money to dress up the cookies so that they will be presentable! Honestly cannot recommend this shop. Waste of my time and money!

This bakery/coffee shop is awesome! I have been a customer since 1984, through Eric Reschke's ownership and now, his son's and daughter-in-law's. It is the consummate neighborhood shop with friendly, caring staff, great danish and donuts and fabulous cakes. The shop is super supportive of the community and take good care of their customers. I'm so glad we have this business in our community!

I had ordered a cake this past week from there and picked it up yesterday. After grilling out dinner I brought out the cake for some friends and my son (who's birthday it was) and served it. At first bite everyone was raving about the taste and texture of the cake. Well done to wyoming pastry as it was a big hit. Will order in the future. Thank you to the person who made the cake.

They had safety precautions in place. They were fast and my 2 favorite doughnuts were still there even though it's been a couple of years since I have been. Cinnamon rolls with apple chunks and what I call.the cherry vanilla open face doughnut! Still delicious

Warm and welcoming like a pastry shop from another era. The cakes and breads are the best. Salty rye famous across town. The cookies are a delight with new fun ideas all the time. Pumpkin coffee fantastic! Love this place!

We love Wyoming Pastry Shop! They have a great variety of sweets and they're all delicious. The employees are always friendly. The pastry shop is a great place to stop in and have a treat or take our treats out to eat in the gazebo across the street.

Wyoming Pastry shop is still the Best Bakery around! Wonderful pecan buns, best rugelach I've ever tasted, just right chewy bagels, wonderful old fashioned chewy rye bread, and great coffee in a quaint store on a quaint upscale street in Wyoming, Ohio. Highly recommended. Try it out!

Neat pastry shop in the heart of Wyoming's business district. They have a decent selection and everything looked good I got their mini key lime tarts. They were reasonably pricedThe crust was a little too buttery but that's the only complaint.

I love this place! I grew up in Wyoming and remember stopping by the Pastry shop after school for a donut. Now, I stop in every friday to get 2 dozen donuts for my coworkers. The staff is awesome and the donuts are MUCH better than Dunkin or Buskens. I also love their specialty donuts (i.e pumpkin with cream cheese icing, cinnamon toast crunch and strawberry dough). This place is definitely worth trying out if you are near the area!

I'm a tattoo artist. I can assure you the WPS does not discriminate against people with tattoos. They have always been beyond friendly and courteous to me. They even created cookies for the opening of my tattoo studio. Complete with images of my tattoos on the cookies. You may have felt that during a rush you were looked over. But to claim discrimination because of tattoos, you couldn't be further from the truth. The Wyoming Pastry Shop is and will continue to be my source of amazing baked goods with outsta

Wyoming Pastry Shop is one of my favorite places to visit. They have some or the best pastries I've ever had, for incredibly inexpensive prices. I can?t stand grocery store baked goods anymore when I can pay the same or less to get much, much better quality here.

Never have i been to a bakery with better baked goods or better service. Ive been coming here for over 50 years. Moved away from Lockland but when I need a cake or just a breakfast doughnut, I drive the extra 5 miles. Excellent!

I spoke to the owner Kim she does not care about her customers nor does she care when a customer makes a complaint. She did our pastries 100% incorrect blamed it on us and would not give us a $40 refund due to the situation. We had to go to Servati?s to purchase other pastries due to this mistake. She is arrogant, rude and not a great business owner due to her lack of good customer service and caring if her bakery makes a mistake. We will never ever enter this establishment again. I will also be telling a

Kudos to the owner, she called me to fix the issue I had with a birthday cake for my son's 40th birthday cake. I really appreciate this so ignore the other post up for not saying I'm sorry.

This is a great local shop, we habe never had a bad experience here. I stop in occasionally with my niece and/or nephew for donuts and milk and they both like to sit in front of the window and chat. The staff are friendly (and patient beyond means)!

The best service and meat you'll find. The owner Jim is extremely knowledgeable about butchering and cooking the various cuts he sells. The quality of meat is second to non, previous only selling prime grade beef, now offering predominantly wagyu beef. Yes it's a little costly, but its worth every penny. The best steaks, steak burgers, and short ribs I've had. The meat is, iny opinion better quality than any steak house I've been to. The other upside is that most of what they sell is locally sourced. The be

Had the red velvet cupcake and chocolate frosted french cruller this morning. The cupcake was one of the best I've ever had and the cruller was perfect.

There was nats flying around in the donut case an landing on the donuts I noticed then said I don?t want the one out of that case the lady that was working got mad and slammed the tray down on the other case. Like so we?re selling donuts that have bugs on them I think I?ll pass on this place that is gross.

We had a terrible experience with this bakery. The cake was a complete disaster and not what we ordered. We have been loyal customers for years and the owner offered to do nothing about the cake. Don't use this bakery, you will be highly disappointed.

Love the cake but they never answer the phone nor call back...edit... so I called they answered and I placed an order. Cake was amazing. Changed my rating after tasting.

I wish I lived closer because I would be in everyday... Absolutely wonderful!!

So apparently they refuse service to people with a lot of tattoos. Unreal. Edit: this is not a false rumor. Apparently the owner would prefer to claim my close friend is a liar, rather than investigate the issue.

Great traditional French pastry shop. Donuts, cakes and pasrties are amazing. No comparison. Coffee is lousy but everything else is worth the drive

Best bakery ever!!! Everything made on site, not shipped in from a local mass produced facility like some other bakeries. High quality ingredients and flavor as a result. Yum.

I ordered my sons cake last minute and they delivered with excellence. It was adorable and tasty i will be ordering all my cakes from here!

They made my son's baptism cake and cookies and they were SO YUMMY and gorgeous! Reasonably priced, great customer service, HIGHLY recommend!

I never had a problem until I found this bakery I do not get my birthday cake no where else I refuse thank you for being a amazing bakery and have the best employees always polite and respectful thank you for having a fat kid like my self only buying here

This is place is #1 in my places of pastries shops their donuts are better that's right I said better the buskens!!! Give me the MAPLE FILLED long johns all day the staff is always pleasant an smiling waiting to serve you... come by an check them out ???

Hello! I'm a ICU nurse at a local hospital and we just received a donation of ? face ?? from Wyoming Pastry Shop. And I just want to say THANK YOU FROM MY ? TO YOURS!?? that was very thoughtful??

I love this place I have been coming here since I was a kid. The staff is very friendly and the cupcakes,cookies and anything else you order are delicious!!!!

Amazing donuts, great cakes, superior bread. The staff has a family vibe and you become a cousin just by walking through the door.

Fantastic shop! The chocolate caramel shortbreads are to die for. Also the only bread I get anymore it's fantastic and super reasonably priced.

I love the Cinnamon toast donuts! Cute little place in a part of Wyoming, Ohio. That is a site to see during spring time!

I'm in love with this pastry shop. The donuts are superior, and the drip coffee is surprisingly good.

Old fashion type bakery. Lots of wonderful products. Very frendly employees. Get there early for the best selection There aren't many places like this left.

Tuesday and Thursday they feature dunking sticks and Saturday has small batch of salty rye! Both pastries are awesome!!

This place is awesome! The service is excellent and their food is fantastic. Their donuts and cookies are top notch!

My friends and I love coming here on Fridays. The staff is welcoming! And their food is the best in Wyoming.

Lived in Wyoming 20 years ago and still dream about there donuts today. ??

They make the best sweets, especially donuts and decorated sugar cookies!

Yum. This was the first time I had been in. We wandered over after lunch at a nearby restaurant. Everything looked delicious and the cannoli I had was terrific.

Best cookies in the state. Me and my Fiance are having them sent to Columbus for our wedding.

They did my baby paw patrol cake it was beautiful I loved it she loved it I give two thumbs up

Love their pastries! Friendly staff and items are reasonably priced!

Local business that has been here forever. However, it doesn't feel stale. Great food here and always friendly service.

The customer service has really gotten low ..Like they don't like working there and numerous times they don't ask who was next and I felt invisible even though I been waiting for five or more minutes....

They have the best pastries and donuts in town the owners and staff are friendly as can be

They makes good desserts. I saw through of the window and it looked so good! ??????

Love the smiley face cookies and sticky buns. On our way now from Newport, Ky.

Pastry attendant was very helpful placing order. Excited to see how the order looks .

My children beg to go to the dentist because it's next door and then they get to go to the pastry shop.

Has the best made daily fresh donuts in the Millcreek Valley area

The best pastry . I grew up in wyoming and as a child we had these pastries.

They are the best. I've been coming here 20 years.