Star Pizza

Star Pizza

Reviews Summary

Star Pizza is generally praised for its delicious, large party pizzas and reasonable prices, with many customers considering it the best in the area. The family-friendly atmosphere and good service are frequently highlighted, though some note inconsistent delivery and phone service. While wings and some sides receive criticism, the steak subs and salads are well-liked. Service quality varies—some experiences are excellent, while others report slow or rude service, order mistakes, and cleanliness issues. Despite mixed feedback on certain dishes and service, loyal customers appreciate the local charm and return for the standout pizza.

About This Listing

Who Can Visit?

Most donut shops welcome all ages—perfect for families and kids
Some locations offer sit-down areas, while others are grab-and-go
No prior ordering knowledge needed—staff can help you choose flavors
Casual dress is welcome—some shops may have outdoor seating
Allergy-friendly options may be available (ask in advance)
Group orders and celebrations welcome—pre-orders may be required

*Note: Seating, menu, and accessibility may vary by shop. Contact your local spot for details.*

First-Time Visitors

First-time guests can simply walk in and browse the display or menu. Staff are happy to offer recommendations and explain specialty flavors. Some shops even offer sample bites or combo deals for newcomers.

Common Considerations:

Allergens Some donuts may contain nuts, dairy, or gluten—always ask if unsure
Availability Popular flavors can sell out early, especially on weekends

*Note: Menus and specials may vary. Ask staff or check online for daily options.*

What to Bring

Cash or card—most donut shops accept both, but some are cashless
Phone or camera—perfect for snapping and sharing your sweet finds
Appetite! Fresh donuts are best enjoyed warm and on the spot

*Note: Payment methods and policies vary by location. Check signage or ask staff.*

Preparing for Your Visit

Check store hours and peak times—early visits offer the best selection
Call ahead for large orders or special boxes
Bring friends or coworkers—sharing a dozen is half the fun
Dress casually—many shops are walk-up counters or offer outdoor seating
Leave pets at home unless it’s a pet-friendly location
Check for limited-time flavors, holidays specials, or preorder events
Set a treat budget if you’re shopping with kids
Bring a reusable bag or box if buying in bulk

*Note: Each shop may offer different experiences—check social media for updates.*

How to Get Started

Most shops accept walk-ins! For custom orders, pre-ordering is best. Ask about gift boxes or subscription options.

Other Helpful Info

Visits usually take 10–30 minutes, unless you're sitting down to enjoy
Weekends can be busier—plan ahead for quicker service
Seasonal or limited-edition donuts often rotate monthly
Some locations offer donut decorating kits or workshops
Gift cards, boxes, and party platters are often available

*Note: Features, pricing, and offerings vary by donut shop. Always check ahead.*

Contact Information

Address

204 W Main St

Mayodan, North Carolina 27027

Hours

Monday 10:30AM-9PM
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 10:30AM-9PM
Thursday 10:30AM-9PM
Friday Closed
Saturday 10:30AM-10PM
Sunday 11:30AM-9PM

Customer Reviews

If you're craving pizza and tired of your basic chain restaurants, this place is a must. They have a large variety of pizza, pasta, subs, salads and more. Great atmosphere and the service was amazing. Prices are reasonable and the food was delicious. I ordered a medium pizza but I'd compare it to a large from most other pizza restaurants. Can't wait to go back and try out some of the other menu options.

We love this place! The quys who cook always remember us when we visit. They take pictures of patrons and hang them on the walls. It's fun to go and see yourself.

I've always had good meals here. I've ate there for lunch and dinner. Staff is friendly and know their menu selections very well. I had their Meat Stromboli and it's one of my favorites.

Great food and very nice wait staff plus owners are always generous and know every by name. Good vibe

Had a cheese pizza for the first time here. Excellent pizza! Definitely the best anywhere close to them. Only reason for the 4 stars was the cornmeal on the crust. Flavor, cheese, sauce, service and price was excellent! Other than the cornmeal the crust was good crispy and thin!

It's surprisingly good pizza ?? ?? and the service is great

The best steak and cheese deluxe sub and meat lovers pizza in Rockingham County.Fast service and great staff.

Steak and cheese subs and star fries are always our go to but the pizza and pasta is amazing as well! love this in our small town

Reliable, local favorite with the best pizza and subs in the area!

The environment was welcoming, and our waitress was pleasant and patient. The food (pizza and fries) were delicious! The prices were down to earth! I like this little family oriented place. I'm from Mayodan, and it's great going home to great people and food! If in the area, stop buy, you won't be disappointed. Thank you, Star Pizza, for being who you are...even on Christmas Eve!

The best restaurants in Maydan service, food quality and friendly staff. Dr.Mohamed Elmahallawy from EGYPT

Tried to do a multi person order for delivery 6/21 at around 830 in the evening. The lady who took the order did a great job, she separated the individual orders and was in the process of giving us individual totals when the manager (possible owner) started giving her a hard time about the order.... He rudely gets on the phone and starts demanding that the entire order needs to be paid on one transaction, or needs to be called in individually.... On top of that prior to taking the phone from her, he was tre

Omg. Top notch. The service, the food, the atmosphere.. all excellent. Coke and Pepsi products, pizza the size of small children. The chefs salad was a thing of art. They make their own dough! Everything tasted fresh and perfect. Thank you thank you. ????

I don't give many 5's. Pizza was awesome and the homemade chips!!!

I always have loved this place! Never gotten food I didn?t enjoy here! Staff has always gone above and beyond to make me and my kids feel right at home!

Great chef salads ?? . Friendly service .

Once again these guys gave my family a wonderful meal after a very busy day. The big pizza was great and the no crust pizza for my daughter and husband was super good. It's always such a pleasure to have somewhere you can get good clean food and such special people as Sam and his crew are. God bless you all for taking such good care of my family when they want good clean food. Thanks Sam. Mrs Massey and family

Amazing wings!(hold off on the water)

We ordered a meat lovers pizza to take home. The pizza was pretty decent for a local mom and pop/small town pizza shop. I would order again if I was local but wouldn?t go out of my way.

Excellent, locally owned pizza shop. They have excellent salads that are huge! Also one of the better cheesesteaks you?ll find. Also love their Star Deluxe pizza or just the plain pepperoni pizza. I make the 30 minute drive just for their pizza when we crave one. Would certainly recommend to anyone I know.

This place is amazing! We always do delivery, everyone is friendly. The party pizza is amazing! Great price! The food is so good and it?s all affordable! I really love getting the cheese steak with extra cheese! The fries aren?t the best though. So I always get onion rings instead.

Very delicious pizza and sub?s

My friend wanted spaghetti so this place popped up I myself ordered a stromboli and I got a calzone which was fine with me I really like the cheesy garlic bread

I enjoy my food to be fresh and kosher Star Pizza has never let me down. The salad is always fresh as crisp and my entree hot and so delicious. I am going to credit this to the owners actually managing every shift to ensure that you receive only the best.

The best pizza we've ever had!

They always delivered to Stoneville now every time we call it?s no not tonight. They need to get their act together the food is ok but they need a better system for delivery and if they don?t want to pay drivers use door dash

Food is decent, I enjoy their veggie pizza. However, I think they keep their phone off the hook on a regular basis. It's almost always busy when I try to call and place an order. When I say it's busy I don't mean you hang up, try again and there they are. I mean you can try to call for 45 mins straight and it'll be "busy". Yeah right. Really seems like they're riding on the fact they're local favorite so they don't care how they treat their customers.

I love this place because it's as close to REAL New York pizza as I can get without having to travel to the ghetto in Greensboro. Their delivery drivers are AMAZING! They need to be tipped more! They say 30-45 minutes and they're to me in 15! Please be kind to them!

We ordered their massive 28in party pizza; there were 4 adults and 2 kids. Pizza was delicious and the price was very reasonable. We still had about a large pizza left over. It was well worth the visit and we will certainly return for more.

I had to give 1 star just to be able to put up review. If they had negative stars I would rate it at -5! Worst calling in experience ever by far. Said they can't deliver if ur more than 3miles away I'm 2.4 miles away and wouldn't take my order to deliver. That's bad business Sam ur employees need to be alot nicer you just lost out on over $60 for a 7 min drive. This restaurant call was rude and unexceptable and you'll never get my service ever again. Ppl reviewing this make sure when u call for delivery to

We went on a Sunday. Not too many people. Big party in the back. Definitely a local spot. Ordered hot dogs and a meatball sub. Both were good but the dogs were deep fried (A pet peeve of mine) and we saw no less that 5 28" pizzas going out the door while we were there. The service was what we expected for a small local place. Will we go back? Yes. This is the kind of local place that we enjoy.

I lived in Philly for a few years and loved the cheese steaks. I have tried for years to find one close to the ones up north. Star Pizza has beaten everyone hands down. Lots of meat and toppings. We also got one of 28" pizzas to feed everyone when we moved our business across the street from them. It fed 7 people with take home left overs. They do not skimp on sauce or toppings. Very good service. Nice folks. I will probably gain 10 pounds being so close.....

The waiters did not wait on us good at all. Our suds came to our table really good but the French fries came to us later after I eaten half of my sub. The French fries was cold we ask the lady to take them back. I ask for my mt dew three times. She was to busy talking and playing with a kids. I'm really dispointed

We work from home and frequently go here for lunch to get out of the house. Great pizza joint...friendly service, good food.

Amazing pizza! Have some of the best I've seen so far. The inside is kept clean, and the people who work there are very nice. The prices are pretty good too. The pizzas are giant! With it being only a few minutes away, we come here quite a bit. Definitely come here for good pizza!

Always great service. One of the few pizza places i will go to. I love everything i have eaten there. Very kind staff. Warm friendly atmosphere. Just awesome all around.

Food is usually good but the wings are just gross. The meat quality is poor and seasoning is greasy butter hot sauce that doesn't stick to the wings. Also,Alfredo has large chunks of garlic that aren't great. Pizza is good though!

The food was good and the atmosphere would have been tired in the 80s! ?? I got the chicken parm sub and found it odd that it was served with lettuce, tomatoes and mayo. The place could use an interior decorator but the service was pleasant. They do make a massive pizza our church uses for large events. There's never any leftover! My wife needs to eat keto and we were very pleased to see a crustless pizzas on the menu! Gluten free folks will appreciate this option too!

I have to say, this is the best of places for comfort food, to include the pizza selection, their salads are amazing, and the steak and cheese subs with fresh chips is the best hands down. I really do appreciate the fact that the food is prepared the way that they would expect and want it themselves. They take pride in the quality given to anyone and everyone. Thank you Sam for a great restaurant and excellent foods. I highly recommend this place for anyone looking for great food.

They have decent food however service needs much improvement have gotten ordered wong 3 times in 6 weeks this is the only pizza place that delivers however this time I am choosing to drive 15 mins to town to get my pizza from Tiaonos because the order person refused to deliver to me over 2.00 even tho I order every weekend!!!! I even offered to give additional money for tip which is free money to the restaurant I guess they should retrain on common sense when taking orders.

Great atmosphere, great service, The owners treat you like part of the family. Really great Pizza, if you haven't been there , you really missing great service, and the food .

Excellent grilled chicken salad. Requested feta cheese which was perfect. The big block feta. House made Italian dressing was superb.

When I visited it was take out only. Did not feel like eating pizza in the car so will wait until they allow dining in.

Fantastic pizza !!!! Wife and me got one for my sons 15th birthday!

Tonight was the first time I ever Ordered a pizza from star pizza. It was very delicious! The meat lovers is what we Ordered. I think they should change the name to 5 star pizza. They get 5 stars in my opinion.

Have never been disappointed with any thing I have ever ordered!!! In fact I was very surprised on how good there food is! & Delivery people are truly Awesome as well! Thanks and Keep Up the Good Food and Great Service!

Pizza was not warm. Cheese wasnt even melted. Wings were dry and had no meat. First and last time we will eat here.

The best Pizza EVER... can't wait for the sit-down part opens back up. I love watching them make the dough and toss it into the air. My husband and I love to taste their raw dough ??p

I have never in my life had the utmost disgust in doing business with the owners of this restaurant. The greed that these people thrive on is utterly deplorable. I've seen them treat their staff horribly too. The exact opposite of what it means to be a brick and mortar business.

Felt like I was a hog being slopped! Said "thank you" several times to the waitress, but never got a" your welcome" back. The order was not read correctly by the cook so of the two orders taken only one came to the table. When the second finally came ( barely warm in the center of the lasagna ) she put it on the table, and walked away without apologizing for the mistake. Needless to say our "tip" reflected this. WE will not be back!

The sloppy wings sweet and Hot is a must try. I've never thought I could eat pizza in another state other than NYC. But I was wrong this is the best pizza I've ever tasted out of state. Even better than some pizza spots in NYC.

Star Pizza is family owned by wonderful & fun people! Their pizza is absolutely one of the BEST!!! They make these huge party pizzas & they can feed 9 people with A LOT left over! Pricing is really good! I totally recommend Star Pizza?? ??

Apparently the air conditioner was broken because it was very hot . The waitress was slow and unfriendly. The bathroom was filthy. The order was wrong and had to be corrected and the waitress said, "Not my fault." And on top of all that the food was not very good. When we paid, the cashier told us that she had just been cussed out by a customer over the phone. I can see why. We will not return. When highway 220 is finished and with 73 extention open between 220 and 68, it will be much easier to get to and

Great food great waitress highly recommend

So professional yet very welcoming. The food is delicious. Love it!

This place is a complete joke! Food quality and customer service is poor! Don't order delivery they'll make you wait an hour and a half to bring you cold inedible food. Buyer beware!! Go across the street to beach house grill and get your money's worth

Had reserved the party room and upon arrival it looked like it had not been cleaned in a week. Only had one waitress to run the entire restaurant plus the party room on super bowl weekend. Took forever to get food and a few in our party did not get food until everyone was done eating. Really felt bad for the waitress but thought management was really not worried about it.

Best pizza hands down????

Always a good place to eat. It's a great family place. They have great pizza and good service. And they have a big back dinning area that can be reserved for birthdays and other events.

I called to see if they were open around 930 pm because Beach house across the street closed an hour early for some unknown reason. Anyways, the very young blonde waitress replied with ?I answered the phone didnt I?? Floored, I walked in to order hoping to deal with someone more mature. ( I have to say Star pizza has great cheese steaks HOWEVER, they done away with their home made ranch which was 80 percent of the reason why I loved star pizza. We ordered about 40 dollars worth of food to go tonight, so my

Awesome food n reasonably priced. Friendly atmosphere.

Never had a bad meal from Star Pizza, very friendly staff as well.

Just found this place a couple of weeks ago and we love it! Took the whole family tonight. Feed 7 adults and a child for beyond reasonable price. We will be regulars

I haven't had anything that was freaking delicious. Everything's so fresh and prepared nicely. Will definitely be back to try everything!

Tried to call for 2 hours to place and order and the phone was ALWAYS busy. It was really disappointing because the food is great! It's really sad but they don't seem to like delivery orders and something's always wrong with the delivery.

Star is a very popular local pizza restaurant. I would recommend it if your in the area. Thanks.

Great pizza just make sure you get there an hour before they close because they shut down the grill early during the week. A little disapointing that I got there at 9:30 when they close at 10 and could not get a steak salad.

I ordered a deluxe steak grinder from stars pizza, not only did they forget to put lettus and tomato on it but there was hair in it as well. When I called the owner "sam" and told him what was going on he began to yell and get very upset with ME because they forgot to add lettus and tomato and there was HAIR in my food, he yelled at me and told me he wouldn't reimburse me or remake it. The health department will be getting a call in the morning. Do not waste your money at this place. This is no way to run a

Pizza was great, the service was amazing, the place is a little run down but still respectable.

Awesome place staff very humble and friendly great food prices are a little high but with the amount of food they give you it's totally worth it absolutely amazing ??

Courteous good food vantastic waitresses good food for the money

Awesome food simply the best owner and staff are so friendly just a great place all around u can't go wrong A++++!!!

I've got either pizza or steak and cheese hoagie. Anytime I want pizza, this is where I go. They also deliver. Nice people there.

I used to order delivery from here twice a week. The last 10 times I have called, they don't deliver those nights. Please get some help.

The waitresses need to write things down so they dont have to ask u 10 times what u ordered. My food was cold so had to send back and there wasnt much meat in them

Got my order wrong after I specifically told them twice no peppers no onions. I will not be back.

Excellent food. My favorite is the pepperoni. We also get a margarita pizza which has no red sauce on it. Also recommend the homemade chips.

Great food, friendly staff.. they really wasn't doing. Dine in service, but made an exception for me...

I love this place! Everything we've tried, which has been several different options, it's always good, great amount and price.

Not as good as to used to be. Chef's salad was huge and good, Cheese Fries were limp, unseasoned and bland, Cheese Steak Deluxe Calzone was ok.

Best everything in town I love this place used to work there and great job great place to eat!

Best pizza around. Great owners. Love this place

Love that this place is pork free! I don't eat pork so learning that made it possible for me to eat pepperoni pizza ?? their pasta is good also

I hadn't been to Star Pizza in years. It was delicious. I think the difference in their pizza is the cheese. It's better than others'.

We have tried different pizza places around and by far the best pizza by far. Definitely recommend the party pizza.

Staff is always on point and never leave you waiting. I go for the huge salads

Called got a sub and some fries asked if the sub came with cheese they said yes. Once I got to work to eat it was no cheese on the sub also the bag my fries was in had fell apart from what seemed to be grease

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I find donut shops near me?

Simply enter your zipcode, city, or browse the list of states and cities. We'll instantly show you the best-rated donut spots around—classic bakeries, trendy cafes, and hidden gems alike.

Are all the donut shops listed verified?

Yes! Every listing is reviewed for accuracy. We prioritize shops with real customer ratings, up-to-date menus, and consistent service.

Can I search by flavor or dietary preference?

Absolutely. Filter by popular flavors (like maple, custard, or vegan chocolate), or search for shops offering gluten-free, keto-friendly, or dairy-free options.

Do these shops offer delivery or pre-orders?

Many do! Listings include details on delivery partners, online ordering, and whether you can reserve boxes for pickup—perfect for gifts or events.

I want to send donuts as a gift. Can I do that here?

Sorry, but we don't support this yet! But we are considering adding this option!

What are “limited-time” or seasonal flavors?

These are exclusive donuts offered for holidays or specific times of year—like pumpkin spice in the fall or strawberry shortcake in summer. Check back often—they go fast!

Is this just for big cities?

Not at all. We’re expanding constantly, including small towns, roadside bakeries, and regional favorites. Sweetness knows no bounds.

What if my favorite donut shop isn’t listed?

Let us know! You can suggest a shop directly from our site. We’ll check it out and add it if it meets our standards for quality and service.