Peachey's Baking Co
Reviews Summary
About This Listing
Who Can Visit?
*Note: Seating, menu, and accessibility may vary by shop. Contact your local spot for details.*
First-Time Visitors
First-time guests can simply walk in and browse the display or menu. Staff are happy to offer recommendations and explain specialty flavors. Some shops even offer sample bites or combo deals for newcomers.
Common Considerations:
*Note: Menus and specials may vary. Ask staff or check online for daily options.*
What to Bring
*Note: Payment methods and policies vary by location. Check signage or ask staff.*
Preparing for Your Visit
*Note: Each shop may offer different experiences—check social media for updates.*
How to Get Started
Other Helpful Info
*Note: Features, pricing, and offerings vary by donut shop. Always check ahead.*
Features
Contact Information
Address
4800 S Tamiami Trl
Sarasota, Florida 34231
Hours
Customer Reviews
Prior to their store opening, I had tried these donuts. Supporting local small businesses is something I'm always happy to do. Nevertheless, I find their prices to be steeper than the value of their food. The pretzel was decent, but a bit too oily for my taste. The provided mustard was a highlight. If you enjoy a doughier donut then you'll likely appreciate these. This time around the donut in my opinion was slightly undercooked. I agree with another reviewer that the donut is somewhat different from the fo
Amazing as always! Donuts are delicious. Sweet and soft! We were patiently waiting for the storefront to open up after missing their truck treats! Thank you for bringing the community what we need most, a little sweetness goes a long way!! ??????
Excellent donuts and pretzels! We've stopped twice on our vacation so far.
These homemade-style donuts are an absolute delight?soft, fluffy, and downright amazing. These pillowy treats, yeast-based for that airy texture, deliver a melt-in-your-mouth experience. And the pretzels are another level of incredible
I eat high end donuts in every city I visit. Peachy's is a TOP TIER donut. Atmosphere is perfect, product is 10/10. Totally amazing. Support local business!
There?s no donuts like these donuts. And the pretzels too- Delicious! And the people who work the donut truck and store and friendly and kind. Love this local, family-owned business. Great new store, so happy to have them nearby. If there?s a line, I promise it?s worth the wait!
OMG! Get a hot doughnut here. You won?t be sorry. Grand opening this weekend. Welcome to the neighborhood! They have a bricks and mortar location as well as a mobile location.
BEST donuts ever!!! Soft, melt-in-your-mouth, perfect, huge, and unlike any donut I?ve had before ?? also their soft pretzels are 10/10!!!! Love the coffee and atmosphere and the owners are so kind. Absolutely worth visiting
The best donuts EVER! Let?s just say I know my way around a good donut and these are my favorite. Service is amazing and everyone is super friendly.
One of the best donuts I?ve ever had. The texture and fluffiness is amazing, taste is amazing. Pretzel was pretty good too, cheese sauce would have made it next level. A bit pricey at $6/donut but they are pretty large
Delicious donuts and the pretzel was amazing!! If you get a chance, try it. You will not be disappointed!
The doughnuts were unbelievably good! My favorites so far. As well as the pretzels! Friendly service, very nicely decorated and clean place. 100% Recommended!
Friendly staff and amazing donuts.
You can tell they're still working out the kinks with the store. They're very busy. but as usual they have the best soft pretzels & donuts! I've been a customer for awhile now, and i'm so happy they got a store! congrats guys!
Love the salt and butter balance of the pretzels.
My first time and Im sorry the Donuts are Not cooked very dough like, Extra cash for a frosted one, I asked for Strawberry but it had these gritty bits in it like raspberry instead, the price is very high for what you get, a larger uncooked doughy very expensive donut, 18 bucks for 3 donuts that were undercooked. Its all hype and I fell for it, it takes advantage of people cash, but thats the world today. Expensive but bad products, they stuffed the 8 dollar donut in a small container breaking it all up a
So tasty! Best doughnut I?ve ever had
Was introduced at Bonnaroo in 2017, and have been following them since. A trip to Miami inspired a road trip to Sarasota and their new brick and mortar, and the donuts did not disappoint!! Thrilled to be reunited with the best donut we've ever had!
Best donuts in the state! Just try one. Thank me later.
PEACHEY'S is one of the best businesses around! Their Pretzels and Donuts are top notch!! They are a great family, so glad they have a location!! In my opinion, you can not get a better donut or pretzel in Sarasota!
Truly the BEST donut you will ever eat. So excited to be able to get Peachey?s all year round! Such a cute place- a must visit in Sarasota!!
Best doughnuts! So happy they have a brick and mortar!!
The doughnuts are yummy and very large. Everyone should try them
Donuts were great but come on forty dollars for a dozen donuts. That's just ridiculous.
Dense and chewy donuts, similar to a beignet. Other donut joints market this style as "cronuts". I like them.
Sooooo disappointed!!! I?ve followed the truck for years, would literally go to the fair just for Peachys. Today they were tasteless, barely any glaze, undercooked maybe I don?t know but the texture was just weird. Dough didn?t taste like the usual. Woke up super early to go spend $40 and they were just bad, threw them away. I?m so confused?!?!
Best donuts and soft pretzels ever!
Love this doughy donut! Chocolate ganache is my favorite!
Delicious melt in your mouth donuts!
Best donuts in the world.
Please update hours of operations. Drove close to an hour just for the location to be closed.
All staff very nice and polite
Absolutely Incredible !!!!