North Fork Doughnut Co. Bay Shore

The staff was super friendly! There was a good variety of donuts on a late Sunday. The donuts tasted fresh, and soft. They are a good size. Next time I will try their coffee inspired by their donuts! Will certainly stop by again next time I'm in the area! Thank you!

Delicious specialty donuts at a reasonable price and friendly service. Really difficult to leave with only 1 ??. I like to buy a bunch because the donuts are big enough to split up for each to try. Their website has a fun monthly flavor list and you can check out what special flavors they're making for the week. There's outdoor seating and branded merch available. Cute storefront with a cool wall design for photos too. Some fav flavors were caramel crumb cake and cannoli. They were recommended to me by my b

This is one of the cutest donut shops ever! The donuts are so soft and fluffy, and the seasonal flavors are to die for. The first one I had was maple bacon (9/10), and I also tried Samoa (8.5/10) and Cannoli (8.5/10). The cold boo was so cute!

I have been craving these doughnuts ever since they were at our event! I cant even begin to describe how amazing they are. The NOFO team came to the 2023 Brides of Long Island Summer Soiree and set up a beautiful display of doughnuts for all of our guests and they were a huge hit! They have so many different flavors you really cannot go wrong! In addition to the table display they brought a super cute doughnut wall that would be perfect at any wedding or event. Our guests raved about them!!

Every time i have a new donut flavor here its the best donut ive ever tried in my life. Obsessed. Also, i love denise she always helps me and shes so sweet!

I have been craving a great donut for weeks but there is nothing better by me than mediocre options. Today I took the drive to Bay Shore because the pictures from North Fork Doughnut Co. looked amazing and let me tell y'all, I was not disappointed. First of all this place is so cool. They have this giant wooden walkman on the wall complete with giant headphones. It is super clean and has a pleasant and welcoming atmosphere. I was immediately greeted by a kind man with the sweetest smile but what was even sw

Truly horrifying experience. Asked about M&M donuts to which they replied with a rude and condescending ?No?. I still wanted to try some donuts. After finding out it was $18+tax for 4 donuts, I was shook and went home donut-less. Big Sad

Nice staff and delicious donuts! The donuts are definitely bigger than your typical donuts shop. Tried their Boston cream and a strawberry cheesecake, and both were yummy! All others looked delicious also.

Lets just say they are the best donuts I?ve had and continue to indulge as time goes by. Each time i have a nofodoco donut, my day is complete. The best thing that could have happened was them opening it in bayshore so its closer to home! Recommended to any other donut lovers. Worth the trip everytime. Just make sure you call before you leave cause i was disappointed once driving 25 minutes to find out they were closed/sold out for the day. Also emailed and got no response which was a disappointment as well

My inner child delighted at the unique variety of their specialty doughnuts! You truly get what you pay for here! Their doughnut sizes are ample, and the price is extremely fair. Highly recommend! Also, because I care deeply about my trans friends, it was nice to see the bathroom was labeled, "All Flavors." :)

Wow! So delicious, but so hard to pick a favorite?the weekly specials are great, the service super helpful and friendly! It?s been a long time since I had a great doughnut?now I have a place to go and can get a hot coffee too! ENJOY!

What a cute little doughnut shop! I have heard great things about nofodoco doughnuts and had to try for myself! These treats did not disappoint! We got Boston cream, churro, jelly, vanilla frosted, and apple fritters. Each pastry was fresh and tasted delicious! We will definitely return!

Feels like a top tier donut place you would find at nyc but it?s here in Suffolk. A large variety of donuts but they are all very good, best description would be like soft and sweet but not too airy like krispy cr?me and they are a little larger than dunking donuts. All varieties of donuts are what you would expect except the jelly filled donut because the jam is incredible I don?t know how a donut place has good jelly like that.

Incredibly sweet cake donuts that would satisfy anyones sweet tooth! I can never finish off their more specialty donuts in one sitting, so it?s nice that they come inside a container. $5-$7 based on the flavor. Always have the kindest staff whenever I?ve visited! I recommend this spot for dessert after a good meal on Main Street!

Cinnamon Coffee- Yummy. Key Lime Pie- it was a hit. Honey lavender- I liked but not my fav Strawberry Shortcake- my favorite, loved the freshness Oreo- Wish it was filled Boston Creme- Good, wish it had more filling! Paid $4.00 each donut My only comment would be that I enjoy when both the doughnut base and the toppings are different for each doughnut. Having a variety of say: old fashioned style, brioche, filled, etc. Overall the trip was good. I enjoyed my cold brew coffee. Only a few people insid

Just two words - Amazingly delicious! It was hard to choose between all the yummy selections, so I went with the server's recommendation of the Samoa doughnut. It was a perfect balance of not overly sweet toppings (toasted coconut with caramel and chocolate drizzles) with classic plain doughnut. Just the right size to enjoy half now and either share or enjoy the other half later.

Hi whoever was the kind lady that worked here or order more than a dozen of donuts tonight at East Islip Stop & Shop for us Nightshift Workers. I really wanted to say thank you so much. We really appreciate it. I had the Oreo and Cream one which was really really Delicious. Tysm again we appreciate your patronage!!??? :D ????????????

bright, vibrant, hip atmosphere with friendly staff. I love the donut themed decoration. it's fun and inviting. now onto the main attraction: the donuts. they had a good variety of donuts when I arrived and some very appetizing flavors. after much debate, I opted for oatmeal cookie, cookies and cream, earl grey, black raspberry filled and the OG glazed. the black raspberry filled was surprisingly good and delightfully messy. the filling-to-dough ratio is high, so the sweet/tart compote oozed out with one

Unprofessional! They have a catering inquiry form on their website that I filled out multiple times and nobody responded to me. When I called, they just told me to inquire through the website and took my information. Still never heard from them. Other donut shops provide much better service.

The donuts are amazing!! Best I?ve ever had, and the people are even better! Dee was very friendly, helpful and really made my day!!! Especially it being rainy. That whole place is amazing. Please keep up the great work.

Very clean and the Walkman for a photo op is creative. Excellent quality donuts! Don't miss out!!!

I loved NoFoDoCo! Special donuts that aren?t like those ordinary donuts, but I give 4 because some menu was just toooo sweet, I think it was a menu with buttercream / Icing. Also I can never visit during weekdays since it closes at 5pm and they sell out special donuts like around 2-3pm even on weekends.

We did too good to go. The donuts were really great. Great variety.

The doughnuts were tasty, the service was lackluster. Located in the heart of Main st. Bay Shore, parking could be difficult. Limited street parking which is metered. There is a lot behind Tullulah's restaurant down the side street which should have spots available (which is also metered). Inside, the shop is so cute and very clean. The prices are part of the reason I'm taking a star off. I just can't see paying $4 a doughnut as a usual thing. It's very expensive for a dozen. Almost $40 quite high. Yes,

Denise served my friend some AMAZING donuts. She recommended the cannoli donut and it's like she knew me personally with that choice. She was absolutely awesome to us and it felt like I was talking to an aunt/family member

Came here with a friend and I'm so glad I did. Even though we arrived right before closing, the doughnuts still tasted fresh, delicious, and not overly sweet! And the lady who helped us was amazing. Definitely want to come back here to see their other amazing flavors and options!

I am reliving my childhood each time I bite into one of their sickeningly sweet doughnuts. These artery clogging treats are my guilty pleasure. The flavors here are found nowhere else, not even in the epicurean haven that NYC is. Today the flavor of the day was the M&M Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Doughnut. It was tongue coating and creatively presented. A pint of Sail Away cold brew, poured from the tap, nicely counteracted the sweetness of the doughnut.

So good! Donuts aren't heavy they have great classic flavors and the Bayshore location has started to bring in some specialty flavors for fall! Loving having a location nearby! Pictured is their #makeitbasic pumpkin spice donut and iced latte!

Good donuts not many selections. Atleast when I went. Good tasting donuts very soft and fresh

Grossly over priced. Horrible service. Bland variety. Horrible service. The person in charge does not even have the decency to remove his ear pod when speaking to customers. $4/$5 per donut is a travesty. Their donuts are all the same donut with little variety between. Instead they just put different toppings. If you're looking for high end donuts then save your time and money and get Doughnut Plant. If you're looking for a regular donut then go to Dunkin'. Either way not worth the time or money and cu

Great place for doughnuts!!! Amazing presentation, well decorated, super clean and well maintained. Def try the Connolly cream doughnut yum yum yum!

Not even close to the value of what they cost. Generic donuts with niche toppings for 6 dollars each. Ignore the store hours that says ?or until sold out?. They don?t sell out. Failed marketing tactic. Just think to yourself before you go in, do you want to spend 70+ dollars for a load of sugar and flour? Sorry to the owner but nothing about your product or overhead justifies the price point you are asking. There could be gold leaf and truffle on your product and it still would be overpriced, never

First time trying it and it?s amazing how soft, fresh and delicious they are. Price is great for the size. I will definitely come back more often for a sweet treat.

Fantastic donuts, the caramel crumb cake might be the best we've ever had, an absolute must-try!

Delicious soft Donuts. If you are looking for a good Donut make sure to stop by.

They have an assortment of huge fresh baked donuts that are absolutely delicious.

Best donut shop on Long Island. There are always delicious flavors, some are always there and some rotate out. But you can?t go wrong here! Also, they?re huge, and a fair price!

The donuts are always great from here but wow did I receive the most awful service this morning. That kid working the front must of either been high or just did not care. Not only was he extremely slow but he messed up on a simple coffee request 4 times in a row and had no clue to what type of milk they even had. When the girl in the back working became frustrated with his performance and came out to help as she rightfully scolded him he literally sat there and starting giggling at everything she said. Wha

Thinking about the time I went a little late in the day, so they didn?t have what I wanted, which is literally so fine. But the lady made me feel bad for saying 6? actually 4 (before she actually got the 6 box out). And then when I pay turns the screen around with a smug face. I left a tip, think it shocked her. Anyways, I went back a few days later on a Saturday morning and a younger guy was there and he was very nice and polite, great vibes. And then he didn?t turn the screen around. I?m not like gonna as

Absolutely loved the donuts!! Went twice within a week. The staff not so friendly or inviting at all on neither day I went. Today the girl didn?t even know when the mini donuts were available and like I said not welcoming to the shop whatsoever.

Holy cow. These donuts are incredible. The environment of NOFODOCO is friendly and welcoming and their donuts are beyond amazing. Felt like Homer Simpson drooling over this box of miracles.

The small variety of doughnuts look as good as they taste! The price is a bit expensive... but I understand why it is that way. The staff is very friendly

Came here for a Food Done It Tour I have had "NoFo Dough" before and I thought it was meh. I came in opened minded figured it may have just been a dud donut i tried. The store was nice it was around 3:30 and they close at 5 there wasn't much left but they had put a box of donuts on the side for us to give us some variety which was very nice. We swapped out one donut. It is decorated nice the donuts look good, but I honestly don't see the hype not sure if I am spoiled by the boom of bakeries providing fresh

They always have a good selection to choose from. Very fresh. A little expensive but they are pretty big and don?t skimp on the topping. They have new doughnuts every week.

The donuts are wonderful but I must say, they aren't as big as they used to be. Used to be able to share 1 donut with a couple of people but today, when I picked them up, was disappointed. I never minded spending 4.50 a donut but now, will think twice about going back.

Been trying to find the appropriate words to describe how fresh and amazing these doughnuts are. No matter what I think of I feel I won't do them justice. If you've never been, I suggest your first experience be with the caramel coffee cake doughnut. After that out-of-body experience you'll immediately realize you're dealing with something on an entirely different planetary level. Location is clean and nice. Staff is super friendly. Pricing is above average, but in this case I don't care. The quality of thi

Amazing Donuts and staff is super friendly also a great place to grab a coffee. I recommend the crumb cake donut.

Donuts are great nice flavor at the bottom they are bigger then my fist haha. But donuts are great!

The absolute best doughnuts I've ever had! Can't pick a favorite because every flavor is delicious!

The donuts are stale :( I bought glazed, cinnamon sugar, crumb cake, chocolate glazed for me and my husband, and they were all stale. So disappointed! Second time coming here, and the first time, they were fresh and baked that day. I don?t know what happened?.

NoFoDoCo Donuts can?t be beat. Loved them so much, we ordered 75 for my wedding. There wasn?t a single one left at the end of the night. Out of town friends always ask me to bring them when I come to visit now!

The donuts were prettier than they tasted, imo. They were good, but if I'm going to eat a donut, I want it to be SSOOO good and these aren't to me.

I got the pineapple upside and an Apple fritter. It was over 10 dollars for the two and I have to say not impressed at ALL! Dry af the pineapple tasted and smelled funny . I hate complaining in fact this is my first time ever leaving a review but for how much u charge for putting a pineapple over a glazed dohnut w not ur own whipped cream n a cherry .SMH I?m kinda insulted by ur pricing

Amazing doughnuts with a lot of variety to choose from and the person who served us was the sweetest lady ever! Highly recommend

Very Delicious, super fresh. A little pricey is the only reason for 4 stars

Wow what a nice addition to downtown Bay Shore. I have had donuts from this location four times already. My two favorite donuts are the Cookies & Cream and Caramel Coffee Cake flavors. The Donuts are huge and pack a lot of flavor. My only "negative" is the price however you get what you pay for here. If you want cheap donuts go to Dunkin then. What you get here is quality ingredients and a chance to support your local business!

Doughnuts are good. Had the Boston cream doughnut $4 topping (chocolate on top) was sweet and filling was just right not super sweet (good balance of sweetness) no super sugary flavor. I would come here again!

The young woman behind the counter was very helpful and provided excellent service. I got a regular coffee and an old fashioned donut. Coffee was good and the donut tasted as if it was probably really good yesterday but may have not been made recently. Otherwise, a very nice shop.

Donuts are huge fluffy and delicious. I usually like more plain donuts but the flavors aren?t overly sweet! The girl who helped me was so nice. I live in the city and I think these are better than most of the gourmet places near me

Highly recommend. My first visit this morning after Nofo popping up in my instagram feed and was not disappointed. They taste as good as they look. Shout out to the pleasant young men Sunday morning who were absolutely pleasant and professionally patient while I chose .

The best donuts one long island. Hands down ?? sooooo fluffffyyy and massive!! Head over early for more to choose from ??

Any of their doughnuts are very good. When I visited their Bay Shore location at first, I said to myself that ?I need to come here every day?. Now they?re making one in Massapequa, and I?m sure Massapequa residents are happy about it.

Great doughnuts- they manage to stay fresh and chewy (I like them chewy) even overnight. Even a pretty good value @$4 each. Only turnoff was that I asked if chocolate could be put on a raspberry jam donut and was turned down. Then moments later I overheard the same staff telling a customer that the doughnuts arrive in the morning and they are "dressed up" in the store, so I'm puzzled why they wouldn't accomodate this wish. Still looking forward to going back.

Ok, I Love doughnuts. Will drive miles to sample a new shop. But a bit too large here. You can't really enjoy something that spikes your blood sugar into the next decade. Nice variety of doughnuts though.

Best donuts I ever had. Both the classic Boston Cream and the original Coffee Cake donut were amazing. Yes they cost more than DD, but then Peter Luger costs more than McDonalds. You get what you pay for.

Unfortunately, I am unable to enjoy the donuts here. They have yet to serve gluten free donuts on their menu. However, the coffees here are fantastic, they have alternative milks and I'm always down here getting an oat milk latte.

Amazing. If you want a quality donut, treat your self by eating these donuts.

The donuts are very pretty and huge, but the taste of the chocolate was off. The chocolate didn't melt in my fingers on a hot day, which was strange, and makes me suspect they add additives that affect the flavor.

The service was great and the donuts are soooo good I would hurt someone for those donuts!!!!!!!

Service was superb by the staff. Donuts were definitely grade A. The frosting, filling, toppings were all on point. The pumpkin latte I ordered required a second cup after the first sip.

I dunno how this place gets a 5 star rating when it grabbed my attention of that to try them out. Simply overpriced for an excessive amount of fluffy dough and lack luster flavor or taste. It looks amazing in the glass case and your like for the price it must be amazing and then the DISAPPOINTMENT HAPPENS!!! Im giving you an honest review I drove half-hr to check these out !!

It's ONLY DONUT HEAVEN! Light, fluffy, incredibly delicious choices and the classics (glazed, chocolate frosted, sugar cinnamon, etc.) are perfect. I've heard that if you live a good life and are nice to people, when you die and go to heaven they give you NoFoDoCo donuts for your first breakfast. Just to make sure you know you're in heaven.

First of all these donuts are huge! Made so fresh and a lot of variety. The girls at the counter were sweet and the customer service was pleasing.. I will be returning

Delicious, and gigantic cake like donuts. Place an order a few days early, and those beautiful things are ready when you pick them up. First time inside the store. I didn't have the time to explore.

First time customer, cappuccino was good,something Carmel doughnut GREAT, apple fritter was ok! Server was great !! Will go BACK

Dessert Cravings, visit this place You will not be disappointed. Amazing staff, clean restaurant!

My experience at No Fo Do Co was outstanding. The service was amazing! Everyone in there was so friendly. The quality of the donuts themselves were incredible! I rate this place a 10 out of 10!

Great fresh donuts . Larger than your normal donut . Haven?t had a stale one yet which I can?t say the same about other places .

Everything look so good for real Taste good Good coffee Fully recommended

Oh yeah this is great after some tequilas

These are my favorite doughnuts and they keep coming up with me and delicious varieties. I?ve gotten these instead of cake for people?s birthday.

Creative, fun donuts can be purchased here. We like to buy an assortment of donuts and cut them up so everyone can enjoy the variety.

These donuts were delicious and huge! Wish I would have taken pics of the other. But since I know I will be back I will update for my next trip!

The donuts are huge and surprisingly delicious. It was a wonderful change from eating Dunkin for so many years. Here's to many more successful years

Never been to the Mattituck location but tried this location today which recently opened up. The staff were really nice and friendly. Doughnuts are one of the best I?ve had and are some of the biggest doughnuts I?ve ever seen.

I visited ny this week and tried two high end donut shops. One was located in nyc, but this place in Bayshore was the clear winner.

Donuts were delicious and not as fresh as I would imagine. It was the end of the day. They didn't have much left. I will review again later on.

Nice place, most of the workers were nice. Stale doughnuts, weak coffee.... Take a ride down the road to Doughnuts for Days, fresh, and delicious, worth the 50 cents extra