Frosted Tops

Frosted Tops

Reviews Summary

Frosted Tops receives overwhelmingly positive reviews, with most customers praising delicious sweets, excellent custom cakes (especially for weddings), and friendly, talented service. Multiple reviewers highlight the owner's creativity, attention to detail, and ability to bring visions to life. Cupcakes, macarons, and wedding desserts are frequently mentioned as standouts. A few negative reviews cite unfulfilled orders, inconsistent quality (comparing cakes to box mixes), and occasional empty display cases. However, the vast majority of customers express strong satisfaction, with many calling it the best bakery in town and vowing to return.

About This Listing

Who Can Visit?

Most donut shops welcome all ages—perfect for families and kids
Some locations offer sit-down areas, while others are grab-and-go
No prior ordering knowledge needed—staff can help you choose flavors
Casual dress is welcome—some shops may have outdoor seating
Allergy-friendly options may be available (ask in advance)
Group orders and celebrations welcome—pre-orders may be required

*Note: Seating, menu, and accessibility may vary by shop. Contact your local spot for details.*

First-Time Visitors

First-time guests can simply walk in and browse the display or menu. Staff are happy to offer recommendations and explain specialty flavors. Some shops even offer sample bites or combo deals for newcomers.

Common Considerations:

Allergens Some donuts may contain nuts, dairy, or gluten—always ask if unsure
Availability Popular flavors can sell out early, especially on weekends

*Note: Menus and specials may vary. Ask staff or check online for daily options.*

What to Bring

Cash or card—most donut shops accept both, but some are cashless
Phone or camera—perfect for snapping and sharing your sweet finds
Appetite! Fresh donuts are best enjoyed warm and on the spot

*Note: Payment methods and policies vary by location. Check signage or ask staff.*

Preparing for Your Visit

Check store hours and peak times—early visits offer the best selection
Call ahead for large orders or special boxes
Bring friends or coworkers—sharing a dozen is half the fun
Dress casually—many shops are walk-up counters or offer outdoor seating
Leave pets at home unless it’s a pet-friendly location
Check for limited-time flavors, holidays specials, or preorder events
Set a treat budget if you’re shopping with kids
Bring a reusable bag or box if buying in bulk

*Note: Each shop may offer different experiences—check social media for updates.*

How to Get Started

Most shops accept walk-ins! For custom orders, pre-ordering is best. Ask about gift boxes or subscription options.

Other Helpful Info

Visits usually take 10–30 minutes, unless you're sitting down to enjoy
Weekends can be busier—plan ahead for quicker service
Seasonal or limited-edition donuts often rotate monthly
Some locations offer donut decorating kits or workshops
Gift cards, boxes, and party platters are often available

*Note: Features, pricing, and offerings vary by donut shop. Always check ahead.*

Contact Information

Address

225 S David St #2

Casper, Wyoming 82601

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 10AM-6PM
Wednesday 10AM-6PM
Thursday 10AM-6PM
Friday 10AM-6PM
Saturday 10AM-6PM
Sunday Closed

Customer Reviews

Can we just take a minute to appreciate how stinking cool this cake is?!? Frosted Tops did a phenomenal job with turning our ideas into this magnificent cake! Our daughter loved it and almost didn't want us to cut into it! Thank you Frosted Tops for always doing such amazing work and always being friendly and helpful.

Cute, smells really good, ordered the Macarons, and ate them for the first time! :) So, yummy! Vanilla, red velvet, and oreo. Definitely recommend the oreo! We don't live here locally, but we will be back! ??

I don't know how you did it. Yet you knocked it out of the park. I've never ordered a cake before. If I ever do, andI'm close to this place. Im getting it from you. You are a master of your trade. An I can tell you truly love your work. My Daughter loved it. Thank you.

We got our wedding desserts through Frosted Tops and we loved everything! We got our wedding cake, cupcakes, decorated cookies, and macarons from them. Our guests loved them! The cookies were absolutely stunning and the macarons were definitely a favorite! We loved working with Kirsten and she made our vision come true! Thank you so much for creating beautiful and tasty wedding treats for us! :)

Amazing! They made our Gender Reveal cake which came out perfect! ?? The interior of the cake was such a deep Blue there was no mistaking the gender! It was so delicious and beautiful, especially since we really came to them with no prior ideas of what we wanted!

I could not be more happy with the birthday cake that Frosted Tops created. I asked for chocolate cake with vanilla icing with the stipulation that it had to be pretty, and to be creative. The cake they provided was perfect for my request and my wife was very pleased with her birthday cake! The cake taste amazing also! Thank you so much!

Frosted Tops did an amazing job for our wedding. The cake tasting was a fun experience to choose our flavors. Our cake was perfectly customized for us! She put three dogs on the cake. No detail was missed? from a little pink on the nose to a spot on a tongue. The guests raved about how delicious everything was! I would recommend Frosted Tops for all occasions!

Kirsten is so delightful! We had her team make our wedding cake, cupcakes, and macarons for our big day. She was so kind and listened to our requests and all of it was sooo good! I wish we had more time to eat all the cake! 100% will order from her again!

We ordered our wedding cake from Frosted Tops and couldn't have asked for a better experience. The cake tasting was casual and fun (who doesn't love getting to try a bunch of different cupcakes), the designer listed to what we wanted and made some professional suggestions, and the final product exceeded our expectations. Everything tasted as great as it looked. Thank you so much! Would highly recommend.

Frosted Tops is 100% recommended for weddings or gatherings of any size that need a stellar dessert. Kirsten was fantastic from the time my wife and I sat down with her to do the cake tasting for our wedding, to the day of and her eye for display and decoration. Each and every flavor we tasted impressed us, and it was difficult to narrow down our choices. Kirsten helped walk us through the entire process, and we knew we were leaving the best part of the wedding reception in very capable hands. You can't go

The owner, Kirsten, is fabulous. She facilitated a warm and inviting cake tasting for our wedding. The cupcakes they make are out of this world delicious.

Frosted Tops did our wedding cake and cupcakes for our big day this June, and knocked it out of the park! We were so thrilled with how everything turned out. We asked for a cake inspired by the mineral pools in Yellowstone, and it turned out better than we could have even imagined. And, everything tasted even better than it looked! We had very few cupcakes leftover at the end of our big day. From start to finish these ladies were awesome to work with! ??

The BEST macarons I've ever had! And the frosting on those cupcakes is heavenly!

Call for an order of just plain frosted donuts for a baby shower. Was told they would call me back after talking to the owner never received a phone call, so finally called them back and was told they will not do the orders. Highly recommend a different company if you?re looking at getting Donuts for any kind of event.

The ice cream and cupcakes were delicious!!! The owner is wonderful too!! LOVE THIS PLACE and will definitely come back!! Our puppy loved her cone!! Thanks again!!

After a miss communication on our wedding cake I was so disappointed. Seeing others 5 star reviews I was shocked how incredibly poor the owner answered to my complaint. The only way I got her to call me was to write a very bad review. However after I wrote the review she did reach out to me. Refunded half the price. What is even more wild is they did an absolutely amazing job on my business cake and cupcakes not even 2 weeks later. I would give them another chance in the future if I needed to.

I am so happy with my service and cake from Frosted Tops. I ordered a small cake for my wedding. I talked on the phone once with an employee and she completely understood my vision. My cake turned out gorgeous and delicious on the wedding day!! ??

I haven't been to Frosted Tops in a while but I went in today and purchased some of the cupcakes since I was walking by the smell of fresh baked cupcakes drew me in. The Coworker behind the counter was very friendly, helpful and made great suggestions regarding the cupcakes, I can't remember what kind I bought but I decided to give in and purchased 6 different cupcakes that were delicious. ?? I don't know the name of this employee but may the owners please let her know how wonderful she is and that she is a

Great variety of yummy cupcakes and macaroons. We came in to window shop, left with six treats. Perfect combination of icing atop a very soft, moist, perfectly textured cupcake. Macaroon? They have you covered: We chose three and devoured one before even making it to the car. Both items have stood up well to a few days in our refrigerator, and a drive back to Denver. Would definitely visit again. Those of you looking for a decadent, beautiful cake should consult this shop: They've got a great portfolio of a

I am a frequent customer at Frosted Tops and I cannot rave enough about how amazing the baked goods are here! The owner, Kirsten, is absolutely delightful, her food is delicious, and she has an amazing staff too! I have ordered cakes for gender reveal parties, bridal showers, birthdays, and gotten everything from cupcakes to macaroons from Frosted Tops and have never been disappointed! I also happen to own a shop here in town that works quite frequently with her and her customers for their weddings and I

Wow. We ordered cupcakes that were barnyard theme and they did an amazing job. The cows were so cute.

They have an extensive selection of cupcakes, but we were looking for donuts and so had those. The owner and staff were extremely attentive and helpful. The icing on and in their donuts were flavorful and well-mixed. Bakery Review Methodology: 1 star: will not return 2 star: may return 3 star: would like to return eventually 4 star: would love to be a regular 5 star: compelled to bring others here

Kirsten was great to work with, very friendly. The cake was a hit! Super happy with everything! Highly recommended

Wow! The German Chocolate cupcakes were amazing! I also ordered a birthday cake here last year and the owner made it to order. She understood when I did not want the hyper-sweet alcohol-based sweetened fillers (that can induce diabetes in many people) in a cake for an elderly person. She made an old fashioned lemon cake with fruit and old-fashioned sugar. It was lovely and no one had a headache afterwards!

How is it that you get such great reviews , but won't even respond to mine? I don't understand why you did not follow through with what we had discussed is all. Have wonderful day.

LOVE this place! When I lived there I ordered cupcakes from them multiple times and they were always so incredible! I lived in a couple different large cities for most of my life, and they are still at the top of my list. Then, we moved away and I called (15 minutes before closing) to ask for delivery and she said she'd be able to do it the next day at 2pm, which was great. BUT, she DELIVERED THEM THAT DAY! Who else would do that? Not just incredible cupcakes, but incredible business/person! LOVE them!!

We live in Illinois so when your 4 year old Granddaughter tells you she wants chocolate cake, with chocolate Frosting, and chocolate chips for Easter you call every cake and bakery establishment until you find the perfect one! Thank you so much for fulfilling the wishes of this sweet little girl for Easter! This Grandma thanks you! She said, "OMGOSH Grandma, these are sooo good!" 5 ?? Great service. The owner talked with me on the phone. It was a great experience. I highly recommend.

I absolutely recommend this place! I ordered a cake for my mom's and aunt's 50th birthday. I asked them to write their names in Russian on the cake and they absolutely nailed it! My mom and aunt absolutely loved it!! The service was great. Thank you Frosted Tops! Definitely will be coming back!

The owner herself is very kind-hearted and her cupcakes are the best I've ever tasted. All of the employees are just as sweet as the bakery is. I definitely recommend this place to anyone throwing an event or if you just have a sweet tooth!

Not impressed. You can get the same quality from boxed cakes. Basic, gritty buttercream on all the cupcakes. Not what I expect when paying $2 a cupcake. The strawberry one was just vanilla cake with dried(?) strawberries and vanilla frosting. Lemon cake is bright yellow which, as someone who has worked in a bakery, leads me to believe the cake came from a mix. The Kit Kat cupcake literally has Kit Kat candy baked into the cake, which results in bites of chewy Kit Kat. We didn?t finish any of the cupcakes wh

Placing a custom cake order with Frosted Tops is really easy. My custom cake order was perfect. Very talented cake designer. I use Fristed Tops for all my special events. They are talented and organized.

This is our family go to for special occasions and everyday treats alike. Amazing staff and beautiful, tasty baked goods.

I ordered a Charlie Blackmon cake for a co worker's Rockies theme birthday and the ladies knocked it out of the park. Best cake I've ever special ordered. And they delivered the cake. I highly recommend.

We love to stop in and are always greeted with super nice service and great cupcakes!

Wonderful customer service, beautiful cake for my brother and it was delicious! Definitely going back

We ordered cupcakes for my sons 5th birthday and they were amazing and very reasonable priced. The staff was friendly and patient so many different flavors it was hard to choose.

Their sweets are great. Definitely worth the money. The lavender and honey and lavender alone are my favorites.

They went above and beyond. Our stars aligned in our last ditch effort to get a cool birthday cake, they came through with amazing style for this Stranger things cake.

I will never go back!! I ordered cupcakes and they did not fulfill my order. I called in the order 36 hours before I picked the order up. No cup cakes for my daughter's birthday!!!

Best cupcakes in town, and the staff is super friendly. Ordered a few specialty cakes and they always make it unique and delicious!

Best place in town for sweets! Kiersten does great, custom work. Easy to work with and she has such great ideas.

Amazing taste and perfect for client gifts! Highly recommend!!

First time to stop in! The ladies are super nice and fun lil shop. Got a oreo and chocolate cupcakes. I will be stopping in when I visit again.

They did the cake and cupcakes for our daughters birthday. Everything was great and the people are wonderful.

I have ordered cupcakes twice, and was very happy with quality and the presentation!

Super awesome cake and cupcakes everything is nice and not dry. I love this shop highly recommend

Macarons are alive and well in Casper, Wyoming! Go early for the best selection!

Beautiful graduation cake. Matched the picture of the design I submitted, perfectly.

Been in there 2 times. And both times. Had nothing in the cold cases. Nothing for sale. Totally disappointed.

Some of the best baked creations in the Casper area. I can't recommend them enough.

Great selection, amazing cupcakes and cookies. Always friendly!

Fantastic little business, fantastic customer service, And the cupcakes, icecream are Amazing also.

The Macarons are absolutely delicious!

Very friendly and helpful large variety easy to find

Friendly staff, fun atmosphere, macaroons are to die for

Love the friendly faces and the unique products.

Super nice people and DELICIOUS sweets!!!

Cupcakes tasted like womp womp

The macarons were awesome

So fun and delicious

(Translated by Google) Hat! (Original) Chapeau!

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I find donut shops near me?

Simply enter your zipcode, city, or browse the list of states and cities. We'll instantly show you the best-rated donut spots around—classic bakeries, trendy cafes, and hidden gems alike.

Are all the donut shops listed verified?

Yes! Every listing is reviewed for accuracy. We prioritize shops with real customer ratings, up-to-date menus, and consistent service.

Can I search by flavor or dietary preference?

Absolutely. Filter by popular flavors (like maple, custard, or vegan chocolate), or search for shops offering gluten-free, keto-friendly, or dairy-free options.

Do these shops offer delivery or pre-orders?

Many do! Listings include details on delivery partners, online ordering, and whether you can reserve boxes for pickup—perfect for gifts or events.

I want to send donuts as a gift. Can I do that here?

Sorry, but we don't support this yet! But we are considering adding this option!

What are “limited-time” or seasonal flavors?

These are exclusive donuts offered for holidays or specific times of year—like pumpkin spice in the fall or strawberry shortcake in summer. Check back often—they go fast!

Is this just for big cities?

Not at all. We’re expanding constantly, including small towns, roadside bakeries, and regional favorites. Sweetness knows no bounds.

What if my favorite donut shop isn’t listed?

Let us know! You can suggest a shop directly from our site. We’ll check it out and add it if it meets our standards for quality and service.