FRESH DONUT

FRESH DONUT

Reviews Summary

Fresh Donut is overwhelmingly praised for its light, fluffy, and warm donuts, often described as the best in Ohio or Columbus. Customers highlight the perfect sweetness, homemade feel, and standout items like apple fritters and cinnamon rolls. The breakfast sandwiches, burritos, and croissants also receive high marks for quality and affordability. Service is frequently noted as friendly and attentive, with occasional mentions of extra touches like free donut holes. A few critiques include inconsistent pricing, credit card fees, and rare service hiccups, but most agree the donuts are unmatched—far superior to chains like Krispy Kreme or Dunkin'. The shop’s unassuming, local charm adds to its appeal.

About This Listing

Who Can Visit?

Most donut shops welcome all ages—perfect for families and kids
Some locations offer sit-down areas, while others are grab-and-go
No prior ordering knowledge needed—staff can help you choose flavors
Casual dress is welcome—some shops may have outdoor seating
Allergy-friendly options may be available (ask in advance)
Group orders and celebrations welcome—pre-orders may be required

*Note: Seating, menu, and accessibility may vary by shop. Contact your local spot for details.*

First-Time Visitors

First-time guests can simply walk in and browse the display or menu. Staff are happy to offer recommendations and explain specialty flavors. Some shops even offer sample bites or combo deals for newcomers.

Common Considerations:

Allergens Some donuts may contain nuts, dairy, or gluten—always ask if unsure
Availability Popular flavors can sell out early, especially on weekends

*Note: Menus and specials may vary. Ask staff or check online for daily options.*

What to Bring

Cash or card—most donut shops accept both, but some are cashless
Phone or camera—perfect for snapping and sharing your sweet finds
Appetite! Fresh donuts are best enjoyed warm and on the spot

*Note: Payment methods and policies vary by location. Check signage or ask staff.*

Preparing for Your Visit

Check store hours and peak times—early visits offer the best selection
Call ahead for large orders or special boxes
Bring friends or coworkers—sharing a dozen is half the fun
Dress casually—many shops are walk-up counters or offer outdoor seating
Leave pets at home unless it’s a pet-friendly location
Check for limited-time flavors, holidays specials, or preorder events
Set a treat budget if you’re shopping with kids
Bring a reusable bag or box if buying in bulk

*Note: Each shop may offer different experiences—check social media for updates.*

How to Get Started

Most shops accept walk-ins! For custom orders, pre-ordering is best. Ask about gift boxes or subscription options.

Other Helpful Info

Visits usually take 10–30 minutes, unless you're sitting down to enjoy
Weekends can be busier—plan ahead for quicker service
Seasonal or limited-edition donuts often rotate monthly
Some locations offer donut decorating kits or workshops
Gift cards, boxes, and party platters are often available

*Note: Features, pricing, and offerings vary by donut shop. Always check ahead.*

Contact Information

Address

1130 Hill Rd N

Pickerington, Ohio 43147

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 8AM-2PM
Wednesday 6AM-4PM
Thursday 6AM-4PM
Friday 6AM-4PM
Saturday 6AM-2PM
Sunday 7AM-2PM

Customer Reviews

Fresh Donut is the kind of place that reminds you why simple, well-made donuts will always beat out the flashy, overpriced spots. Tucked away in an unassuming location, this small shop delivers exactly what you want from a neighborhood donut joint?fresh, soft, and perfectly sweet pastries that hit the spot. The selection is straightforward but covers all the essentials: classic glazed, cake donuts, filled options, and a few twists like cinnamon rolls and bear claws. The glazed donut is a standout?light, ai

Super easy to order online. Great donuts of all kinds. We bought a bunch for students for an art project and they loved them! Hard to get ahold of by phone tho!

We try to stop every Sunday morning! The donuts are so fresh and light. Always friendly! We have made this our donut shop!!!!

Fresh Donut: A Taste of Nostalgia and Perfection ????? Fresh Donut is hands down the best donut shop in all of Ohio, and I don?t say that lightly. From the moment you walk in, the aroma of freshly baked donuts transports you back to simpler times?when Saturday mornings meant heading to the corner bakery with your allowance in hand, ready to indulge in a well-earned treat. Every bite of their donuts is pure bliss, just like the ones I cherished as a kid. The flavors are perfectly balanced, the textures ar

Their door dash app is awful. You have no way of selecting the exact type of donut you want, you kind of just pick a certain style of donut and hope that they send you the icing you want or even the donut or burrito that you ordered. We originally made our order and we're told one of our items was out of stock so we replaced it with something else. Then right before the order showed up we were refunded for two of our donuts that weren't in stock leaving us with a delivery of only two donuts and a croissant

These donuts were put here to make you smile. They are so delicious. The staff is fast and friendly. I?ve been a few times but they?re always sold out. Now I understand why. By the way their breakfast sausage croissant was good as well. Get you some!

My husband & I visited here on a Saturday @10:00AM. Had plenty of doughnut varieties! Staff was smiling & extremely nice. They have their menu posted here online, you looked up the place so you could easily look up the menu for pricing. They are still new & figuring out things. My husband is from California and has been DYING to find a doughnut shop that taste like home and THIS SPOT was it for him! We will most definitely be back. They are working extremely hard and they?re very appreciated. ???? You can t

As the name says, fresh donuts. They were very light, fluffy, fresh, and warm. Great pricing for being fresh made. They also have some breakfast sandwiches, wine, and alcohol.

Amazingly kind people working here! They were running low on sprinkled donuts, but it was my 4 yr old son's birthday so I just asked if they would have any more coming out soon. Unfortunately it wouldn't be for a bit but the kind woman working the register grabbed some donuts and did them all beautiful for him right there on the spot!! Absolutely amazing service that is becoming a lost art anymore. Thank you so much for making his day today! Oh AND they always throw in extra donut holes just to fill up the

This is one of those hidden gems. The donuts are airy and light with thick, flakey glaze. They taste very fresh and not at all stale or heavy like major chains around here. The burritos are simple and tasty. We didn't get here early enough to try the kolaches nor the apple fritters, but we will have to make it a point to do so! They were very pleasant and fast. I really recommend trying this donut shop! If you are thinking of eating in the shop, there's not much space and keep in mind, your kids will be co

Our favorite place to get donuts. No one else around compares. Just make sure to get there before they sell out

So glad we found this place. They have the most light and fluffy, fresh tasting donuts. Get there early so you get your favorites.

this is the second best donut shop in Columbus donuts, real light and fluffy. 10/10 do recommend

These donuts are absolutely bangin!! The next morning they were still just as soft as when I got them. The 2 young ladies working were very nice. My grandbabies gave em a 10 out of 5!! We will be returning

I love the idea of supporting small locally owned businesses. This one will have some work to do if it?s going to survive. The whole experience seems poorly planned. Of the two glass doors at the entrance, one was locked. No one seem to know where to stand, coffee wasn?t brewed? The service was fine, but not overly friendly- oh yeah, AND THEY WERE ALMOST TOTALLY OUT OF DOUGHNUTS AT 7:30 am?

Seriously the best donuts in all of Columbus. Every time I give these to someone, they have to know where I got them and they always say they?re the best as well. Always fresh. Plus great people. Also try their breakfast burritos. You won?t regret it.

They people are very kind, definitely ma and pop feel. The donuts were good but overpriced, $20 for a dozen. The coffee was a little watered down for my preference. There was no where to set my donuts while I made up my coffee - seems silly I know but they could think through the design a little bit more. And the place needs a thorough cleaning. I couldn?t look real hard because I started to get too grossed out to eat my donuts.

I love your donuts. They are always consistent and delicious. However, this weekend something changed and they have been "wet". The only thing I can think of is the change in the box or maybe the consistency of the glaze. The glaze is not hardening. I ordered more donuts today (Sunday) because I thought it was a fluke yesterday. But, both days the same thing...wet donuts. I hope you can get this problem fixed. Nobody wants a wet donut.

the glaze donut is BETTER THAN KRISPY KREME. There I said it. Seriously though, I?m amazed that the glazed donut tastes so amazing. The other donuts are just as delicious and I?ll definitely be coming back for more!

Seriously the BEST donuts I?ve EVER had. They?re so light, fluffy, and fresh of course! Oftentimes, your donut is still warm! Their breakfast sandwiches are also amazing! Prices are very affordable as well. This place is our go to!

My favorite donut shop! These donuts are amazing! The service has always been great!

Fresh donuts has the best donuts in time The donuts is always fresh made from scratch. The service is excellent their breakfast sandwiches are made from scratch. Taste great and the service is damn excellent my opinion overall the best in town overall

I've been coming here for years and donuts are so awesome.

Me and my friend got some donuts and omg there divine like they are so soft Tim Hortons can?t do better it needs more ppl

This place is amazing!!! They have all your breakfast wants. Kolaches, donuts even breakfast tacos and sandwiches!!! Delicious!!

This shop is in a strip mall and just know that appearances ARE deceiving. These may be the best and definitely the freshest donuts I have ever eaten. Expect to wait in a line and sometimes the choices are few if they are really busy but it is still worth it. I even love the donut holes and I think they were like a dollar something for a dozen. Definitely worth a try.

Just stopped by,,got chocolate iced creme stick , ham egg cheese burrito and sausage egg cheese burrito. Donuts fresh ,melt in your mouth, icing really good flavor but could use bit more creme filling. Both burritos fresh and great flavor. Everything looked good. Store clean. Staff friendly and helpful.

First time here, the donuts are insanely good. I would suggest getting there early because it appears that they sell out fast!

This place is pretty solid. Donuts are great. I really love the apple fritters. I always get the bacon egg and cheese burrito. Most importantly it all felt affordable which kept me coming back. Now every time I go back in I feel like there is a price hike. People are super nice though.

Floored by the price and value of the breakfast wraps. Went first time today, doughnuts soft, fluffy, delicious. Was expecting that based on the reviews. Best glazed doughnut I've ever had. The free doughnuts holes a nice touch. But the wraps- just over $2, full of egg, a thick piece of bacon and cheese- and she heats it for you so you can eat warm right away. Same with sausage kolache- fantastic. Found my new fav cheap eats breakfast place. Was not sure about selection left at noon on a Thurs but it was a

I have to be honest with you all...I didn't want to share my donuts with my children. There is some type of magic potion in these donuts. They are light and fluffy with the perfect level of sweetness. They taste homemade for sure! These donuts are heaven sent for sure!

The BEST fluffy donuts! And the breakfast croissants are next level, I have never had a more delicious breakfast sandwich anywhere ever! Support this amazing local business!

My mom bought some donuts last week and I loved how fresh, soft and fluffy the donuts were. I came in today to buy some kolaches because I really want to try them. I got the sausage and the fruit ones. The kolaches were huge and the fruit filling taste like real fruit. The woman working there was very nice and she even gave me an extra donut. I'll gladly support a local business.

Pretty good donuts over all, I liked them. A little smaller for the price than other places you might be able to get but not dramatically. The apple fritter was *chef's kiss*. Also I'm so sick of all these cake donut places like duck donuts, dragon donuts, etc. Nice to have a new yeasty type donut place.

Donuts are soft, fluffy, FRESH, and the best tasting around. Cinnamon twists are my favorite, but the cinnamon rolls, apple fritters, and donut holes are just as delicious and amazing. No donuts compare to how melty and sweet these donuts are.

I had a taste for breakfast for lunch so I decided to try this place out for the first time. I ordered a breakfast sandwich and donuts but was astonished to see that all the breakfast sandwiches made that morning were sitting out in a display case all day!!! The meat was dried out & dark (almost black)! They were not kept in a refrigerated display case. Just sitting out all day!!!! The donuts all looked like a child make them. Looked NOTHING like the pictures (& I understand most don?t) but these were

My kids LOVE going every Sunday for the yummiest donuts on the planet! ?? customer service is EXCELLENT and fast service! The twist are my absolute favorite! My little ones LOVE the icing with sprinkles they?ve just about had every flavored icing! 5 ??!

Someone brought these into the office and they were SOOOO GOOD!!! I wish I lived closer because this would be my new favorite donut shop! They had a very light and airiness to them, similar to Krispy Kreme if you prefer that style. I had a maple glaze and a couple donut holes, and nothing lasted long enough for me to get any pics!

My sister got me hooked to this place is the best donut I?ve ever had way better than Krispy Kreme donut.

Delicious and very fresh donuts. Only advice would be to work up a system so you don?t run out of donuts every weekend in the morning! Other than that, super happy this shop is in our community.

I ordered and paid for donuts a day ahead and scheduled a pickup time for the next morning. When I arrived they hadn't pulled my donuts and boxed them yet so they were out of some of the donuts that I ordered. The whole point of ordering them ahead of time is so they DON'T run out of what I want. I asked why they hadn't pulled and boxed my donuts that morning when they texted me that they had received my order and that it would be ready at 9:30? They said the donuts wouldn't be fresh and that they had custo

Went in for donuts. They have delicous donuts and breakfast sandwich selections -- but you need to go early. They have coffee, a variety of cold beverages, and great donuts. This bakery has been busy since day one. Give them a try. Selections were low at 10:30am. Warning they close when out of donuts & are now closed on Mondays

This spot in Pickerington has great pastries. I don't have to go across town to the famous bakery on Livingston. Because Fresh Donuts are just has good. You won't find cakes or cookies, though. They do have some breakfast foods to choose from. Closed on Mondays.

First time stopping in. The lady who helped me didn't speak a word to me until we were almost completely checked out. I had to check the screen for the total. Then she told me the total after I had the money already ready. She did finally politely smile and said have a nice day. Donuts were soft and yummy. My "Long John" was not stuffed but just had the custard in a strip down the middle but still good.

Don't listen to the 1 star reviews! It takes time to work out kinks and figure out your supply/demand and get things running smoothly. Depending on when you go in they may be out of some donuts...so what? They are delicious and go quickly. Burritos are really good and super cheap, and the kaloche is fantastic. The only thing I didn't love is the croissant sandwiches but that's just me. Stop in; you won't be disappointed.

Came here to try there Kolaches as I grew up in Texas and missed my Shipleys. Kolaches are good, not as good as Shipleys but they get the job done being as far away from home as I am lol. Donut holes are yummy as well. Will def be back.

I visited for the 1st time today. I got the Doughnut holes and the Jalapeno Kaloche. Very , very good. The price was right on target for what you get. To those leaving negative comments about their service... Give them time to get their works in order. It's hard to gauge how many doughnuts to make to not to be wasteful... And when something like that is good, us customers buy all we can, when we can. They were almost out of doughnuts when i got there also. What i was able to get was amazing. I'll plan to g

Absolutely excellent!!! The prices are amazing and the donuts are BEYOND FRESH. Unlike other the donut shops nearby, these donuts are sugary and filling but don't make me feel like I've overdosed on sugar! Honestly this place is awesome!

This shop needs more time to work out their kinks. My son and I visited Sunday morning at 7:15. There was a line of around 6 customers in front of us when we arrived. There were no menus or prices posted, but I will assume that the tv monitors behind the counter would normally show the menu if they were on. We waited in line for a few minutes, but the line was moving slowly and we could see that the display case was more than half empty. There were very few donuts left except for the donut holes and kolache

Sooooo soft and fresh. So far we?ve tried the glazed, iced, iced w/ sprinkles, chocolate glazed, strawberry jelly-filled, donut holes and the sausage kaloches. We?ve gone twice this week and unfortunately for my wallet, this place is on our way home from church, so I?m sure we?ll be back at least weekly. So glad to have a new donut place around!

Almost no donuts were available. I tried a ham and cheese roll, which tasted like a Pillsbury crescent roll with a piece of lunch meat ham and a slice of American cheese in it. It was ok, but nothing special. They keep the rolls containing meat sitting out unrefrigerated, which is concerning. I expected better. Maybe use some better ingredients to elevate it a bit? Good quality ham and some Gruy?re would be nice. Invest in a refrigerated case. Did the health department approve that food storage?

The best donuts we have had. They are so fresh, and delicious. The variety is great. We won't be getting donuts anywhere else from now on. The whole family is hooked.

Seriously the softest donuts I've ever had. Great variety and delicious. It seems like Columbus' best kept secret so check it out if you're there

The glazed donuts here are really something to write home about! They literally melt in your mouth. Breakfast burritos are ok. Once they sell out for the day they are done. Worth going early.

Donuts were ok, however every single donut rang up higher than the listed price. I didn't say anything about the incorrect(higher) prices, but then they charge a fee on top of it if you pay without credit card. No one mentioned that. I feel like this is deceptive practice

Donuts were fresh and delicious. They were busy, but quick. It's nice to have them in Pickerington especially since the only alternative in our town is stale Tim Hortons donuts. Highly recommend Fresh Donut!

I love this place! The breakfast sandwiches are great and affordable and we love their burritos as well. I grab a dozen donuts for work on a weekly basis. The donuts are always fresh and its good to support a local business!

We visited on a Sunday morning around 10am and most of the donuts were gone. I have to agree with several other people on here that the service was sub-par and the donuts just didn?t look like anyone put any effort into them . If you like glazed it?s s good spot , but I was not a fan of the other donuts . I think they could definitely have a good thing going with a few tweaks.

My 4 yr old has "eaten" Dunkin, Krispy Kreme, and Timmy Ho's and other local stores but typically eats the frosting, leaving the donut. Our first trip to fresh donut today, and she ate the whole sprinkle pink frosted! Pretty tasty

Phenomenal donuts. But they close randomly. Assuming when it?s slow? You should stay open for your posted hours.

Donuts are good if they are ever in stock. For being a donut place that has been around for about 2 years there is no reason they should be sold out and closed at 10:30am on a Sunday.

we got two burritos which were small but filling. we also got two apple fritters and one sprinkle donut which they were so good, the dough was like any other i?ve tasted and the texture was flakey and flavorful. we only spent $6 too, very affordable!! definitely my new favorite brekkie spot:)

I have gone in twice and have to say their donuts are very good. Was in today which is Saturday and everyone else had the same idea so there weren't many donuts so they may have to double up especially on weekends in Pickerington. Would recommend also like their kolaches!!

This donut shop never disappoints. Unless it's 2:37pm and you didn't know they closed at 2pm. Never had donuts so good the first day they're even better the next 10000000000000 stars

Great service with a smile, good menu options and wonderful donuts!

Stopped in for the first time today and I am glad I did. The Jalapeno Koloche was a little less spicy than I would have hoped for but the pastry and sausage were delicious and c'mon where else am I getting a Koloche in Pickerington? Had a Long John and Strawberry Jelly filled as well....don't judge me it's a Friday after a long week. I thought everything tasted fresh and delicious! Saw some complaints on here about them being out of things...that's what you get at a local spot that makes it fresh daily! Pa

The donuts are AMAZING. They?re so soft and fresh. The breakfast sandwiches and burritos are also very yummy. Yes, they?re still working out some kinks but give them a little grace.

Even though it was later in the morning on a Friday, they still had a good assortment of fresh donuts. They really hit the spot too. Fair prices and they through in some little donut holes, so bonus!

Good donuts reasonably priced and great people. If you?re looking for donuts that aren?t from a chain (Tims, Krispy, or Dunkin), this place is worth the visit. Coffee is exactly what you?d expect from a donut shop. I plan to go back and try the non donut breakfast items.

Absolutely the best bakery I have ever been to. Amazing donuts and the hot breakfast options are fantastic as well. The owner and staff are so nice, just a great experience overall

It is nice to have local businesses and support them. I would not say that the donuts are anything special though. We thought they were chewy and not all that tasty. Would rather drive to Lancaster and Donut World.

First impressions mean a lot when trying a new restaurant. Unfortunately, when you have a selection of 2 doughnuts (literally 2 doughnuts and not ?types? of doughnuts) you cross the restaurant off your list. Three other customers walked in and right out due to no inventory.

Really bad donuts. Jelly filled aren?t filled, just a dollop on top. Long Johns are mediocre. Danishes and turnovers suck. Glazed donut is halfway decent. Just stay away, it?s not worth wasting your hard earned money on it.

Great donuts! We needed to grab something quick and these came up on the gps as the closest. We are from Tennessee and where we live are some really good donuts. These weren?t as good, but still pretty tasty!

I bought 2 dozen donuts and they were great! Fresh tasting and the place is clean! Friendly young lady to serve ! Thank you.

I absolutely love this place. Freshest donuts i've ever had. Every single person that works there has always been very happy and nice to me.

Amazing donuts, amazing people. First time visiting and I picked up 2 dozen donuts for the team at work?a big hit. Great customer service and delicious donuts.

The donuts are so fresh and taste amazing, even though we purchased after noon. Very nice. We needed a good donut shop in Pickerington.

Got a dozen day one and had half of one. Woke up next day hoping for a donut and locusts swept through and ate every last one of them. I asked hubby and son if they saw anything, they claim deliciousness.

This place definitely has that "hole in the wall" feel but just as the name on their signs says... They make FRESH DONUTS! Love this place! Try their apple fritters! The best you will ever have!

Super fresh and delicious! My new favorite and do close to home. Also not expensive if you go there. The food apps are ridiculous! You won't be sorry.

The donuts here are so good. They are even good the next day and do not dry out and the people who work there have been really nice each time.

I stop in often to pickup some treats for my coworkers. I love this donut shop, always fresh yummy donuts ?? ?? I stop in about 6am and the donuts are always being made fresh. TRY THEM!

Their donuts are so light and airy - delicious! The owners are extremely nice and always courteous and helpful!!! Thank you.

Always fresh, delicious, and quick friendly service! Pickerington is lucky to have Fresh Donuts!

Best hidden gem! You will not be disappointed if you want fresh, delicious donuts and breakfast items. Kitchen is on site and you can tell it is made well.

Super fresh donuts. If you get there when they open the donuts are still warm! Long John?s are definitely my favorites.

Sells out every Sunday it seems, hours earlier than closing is posted. Seems you should just update the hours, and close sooner.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I find donut shops near me?

Simply enter your zipcode, city, or browse the list of states and cities. We'll instantly show you the best-rated donut spots around—classic bakeries, trendy cafes, and hidden gems alike.

Are all the donut shops listed verified?

Yes! Every listing is reviewed for accuracy. We prioritize shops with real customer ratings, up-to-date menus, and consistent service.

Can I search by flavor or dietary preference?

Absolutely. Filter by popular flavors (like maple, custard, or vegan chocolate), or search for shops offering gluten-free, keto-friendly, or dairy-free options.

Do these shops offer delivery or pre-orders?

Many do! Listings include details on delivery partners, online ordering, and whether you can reserve boxes for pickup—perfect for gifts or events.

I want to send donuts as a gift. Can I do that here?

Sorry, but we don't support this yet! But we are considering adding this option!

What are “limited-time” or seasonal flavors?

These are exclusive donuts offered for holidays or specific times of year—like pumpkin spice in the fall or strawberry shortcake in summer. Check back often—they go fast!

Is this just for big cities?

Not at all. We’re expanding constantly, including small towns, roadside bakeries, and regional favorites. Sweetness knows no bounds.

What if my favorite donut shop isn’t listed?

Let us know! You can suggest a shop directly from our site. We’ll check it out and add it if it meets our standards for quality and service.