Back to Directory
Bill's Bake Shoppe

Bill's Bake Shoppe

Reviews Summary

This bakery consistently earns praise for its delicious baked goods, including donuts, pastries, bread, and cakes, with many highlighting their fresh, homemade quality. Excellent service and friendly staff are frequently mentioned, along with the bakery's charming, old-school vibe. While most reviews are highly positive (5-star), a few note occasional issues like inconsistent hours or higher prices. The pizza shells, cinnamon rolls, and banana cake receive special acclaim. Minor criticisms include limited availability (selling out early) and rare operational hiccups, but overall, it's a beloved local gem.

About This Listing

Who Can Visit?

Most donut shops welcome all ages—perfect for families and kids
Some locations offer sit-down areas, while others are grab-and-go
No prior ordering knowledge needed—staff can help you choose flavors
Casual dress is welcome—some shops may have outdoor seating
Allergy-friendly options may be available (ask in advance)
Group orders and celebrations welcome—pre-orders may be required

*Note: Seating, menu, and accessibility may vary by shop. Contact your local spot for details.*

First-Time Visitors

First-time guests can simply walk in and browse the display or menu. Staff are happy to offer recommendations and explain specialty flavors. Some shops even offer sample bites or combo deals for newcomers.

Common Considerations:

Allergens Some donuts may contain nuts, dairy, or gluten—always ask if unsure
Availability Popular flavors can sell out early, especially on weekends

*Note: Menus and specials may vary. Ask staff or check online for daily options.*

What to Bring

Cash or card—most donut shops accept both, but some are cashless
Phone or camera—perfect for snapping and sharing your sweet finds
Appetite! Fresh donuts are best enjoyed warm and on the spot

*Note: Payment methods and policies vary by location. Check signage or ask staff.*

Preparing for Your Visit

Check store hours and peak times—early visits offer the best selection
Call ahead for large orders or special boxes
Bring friends or coworkers—sharing a dozen is half the fun
Dress casually—many shops are walk-up counters or offer outdoor seating
Leave pets at home unless it’s a pet-friendly location
Check for limited-time flavors, holidays specials, or preorder events
Set a treat budget if you’re shopping with kids
Bring a reusable bag or box if buying in bulk

*Note: Each shop may offer different experiences—check social media for updates.*

How to Get Started

Most shops accept walk-ins! For custom orders, pre-ordering is best. Ask about gift boxes or subscription options.

Other Helpful Info

Visits usually take 10–30 minutes, unless you're sitting down to enjoy
Weekends can be busier—plan ahead for quicker service
Seasonal or limited-edition donuts often rotate monthly
Some locations offer donut decorating kits or workshops
Gift cards, boxes, and party platters are often available

*Note: Features, pricing, and offerings vary by donut shop. Always check ahead.*

Contact Information

Address

228 N Liberty St

New Castle, Pennsylvania 16102

Visit Website Call Now Get Directions

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 9AM-4PM
Wednesday 9AM-4PM
Thursday 9AM-4PM
Friday 9AM-4PM
Saturday 9AM-3PM
Sunday 9AM-2PM

Customer Reviews

The building may look run down but the baked items were delicious. The staff was very friendly and were able to accommodate my last minute order for a birthday party. Everyone at the birthday party raved about the taste. Please don?t judge a book by it?s cover.

Absolutely loved the authentic old school charm of this bakery! Not to mention the baked good are delightful ??

Best fresh backed bread and sweets in the area. Fast friendly service decently priced

Ordered a birthday cake for my dad, had it done in 1 day. Most delicious banana cake I've ever had. Buttercream icing is perfect. We have for sure found our new cake place. My dad was incredibly happy with it. Can't wait to try more stuff!!

I bought several items here a couple of days ago. Everything tasted so good that I wanted to pick up some more this morning. The site says they open at 7:30, so I arrived at 7:26. It is now 8:07 and the shop is still closed!!! Very disappointed.

We buy the pizza shells often! They are the best. We love the mini pies and donuts too. Of course the service behind the counter is excellent too!

Ordered my son's first bday cake here, marble with whipped cream icing, and everyone loved it. The donuts are very good too!

Yesterday was my first time stopping in. Wish I'd have stopped long ago. The pastries were delicious, amd the lady that served me was so sweet.

Great down home just like grandma used to make goods. Love there is still a place like this in New Castle. Highly recommend, just get there early they sell out quick.

The hours are difficult for people who work, but Bill makes some good bread. The pizza shells are worth having, and the monkeybread is great.

This place IA a disaster

Great donuts just get there early to get them fresh thoss are the best There pastries are great to

He was the nicest person I ever met. If you didn't see what you wanted he made it for you right there.

Its very good me an DDT my wife always go there together.

Good product, but very expensive. OK for a treat or holiday, but with better prices you could go more often.

Love the Place......Awesome Food......old flavor Charm!!!??????????????

Had a variety of pastries and bread. They were delicious!

Very good donuts! Excellent service

There is one word that perfectly describes all my purchases here....Yum!!!

Always delicious never a bad experience!

Amazing ?? ??? banana pepper bread!!??

excellent service great food

Very good cinnamon rolls

Always friendly, tasty items.

The best pastries in town mahoningtown

Excellent service..Excellent foods ...

Great service and goods

I love this bakery ??

Everything was amazing!!

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I find donut shops near me?

Simply enter your zipcode, city, or browse the list of states and cities. We'll instantly show you the best-rated donut spots around—classic bakeries, trendy cafes, and hidden gems alike.

Are all the donut shops listed verified?

Yes! Every listing is reviewed for accuracy. We prioritize shops with real customer ratings, up-to-date menus, and consistent service.

Can I search by flavor or dietary preference?

Absolutely. Filter by popular flavors (like maple, custard, or vegan chocolate), or search for shops offering gluten-free, keto-friendly, or dairy-free options.

Do these shops offer delivery or pre-orders?

Many do! Listings include details on delivery partners, online ordering, and whether you can reserve boxes for pickup—perfect for gifts or events.

I want to send donuts as a gift. Can I do that here?

Sorry, but we don't support this yet! But we are considering adding this option!

What are “limited-time” or seasonal flavors?

These are exclusive donuts offered for holidays or specific times of year—like pumpkin spice in the fall or strawberry shortcake in summer. Check back often—they go fast!

Is this just for big cities?

Not at all. We’re expanding constantly, including small towns, roadside bakeries, and regional favorites. Sweetness knows no bounds.

What if my favorite donut shop isn’t listed?

Let us know! You can suggest a shop directly from our site. We’ll check it out and add it if it meets our standards for quality and service.