Biagio's Donut Shop & Pizzeria

Biagio's Donut Shop & Pizzeria

Reviews Summary

Biagio's receives mostly positive reviews (many 5-star ratings) for its delicious, soft donuts with nostalgic appeal, often considered superior to chains like Dunkin'. Fans praise the variety, freshness, and affordability, with some calling them the best in the region. However, consistency issues arise—some note declining quality, skimpy fillings, or burnt items (especially pizza). Complaints include limited early-morning availability, unreliable hours, and occasional cleanliness concerns. A few miss old favorites like cinnamon roll donuts or classic glazed with holes. Cash-only policy and long lines are minor drawbacks. While many adore the old-school charm and service, others feel recent changes have diminished the experience.

About This Listing

Who Can Visit?

Most donut shops welcome all ages—perfect for families and kids
Some locations offer sit-down areas, while others are grab-and-go
No prior ordering knowledge needed—staff can help you choose flavors
Casual dress is welcome—some shops may have outdoor seating
Allergy-friendly options may be available (ask in advance)
Group orders and celebrations welcome—pre-orders may be required

*Note: Seating, menu, and accessibility may vary by shop. Contact your local spot for details.*

First-Time Visitors

First-time guests can simply walk in and browse the display or menu. Staff are happy to offer recommendations and explain specialty flavors. Some shops even offer sample bites or combo deals for newcomers.

Common Considerations:

Allergens Some donuts may contain nuts, dairy, or gluten—always ask if unsure
Availability Popular flavors can sell out early, especially on weekends

*Note: Menus and specials may vary. Ask staff or check online for daily options.*

What to Bring

Cash or card—most donut shops accept both, but some are cashless
Phone or camera—perfect for snapping and sharing your sweet finds
Appetite! Fresh donuts are best enjoyed warm and on the spot

*Note: Payment methods and policies vary by location. Check signage or ask staff.*

Preparing for Your Visit

Check store hours and peak times—early visits offer the best selection
Call ahead for large orders or special boxes
Bring friends or coworkers—sharing a dozen is half the fun
Dress casually—many shops are walk-up counters or offer outdoor seating
Leave pets at home unless it’s a pet-friendly location
Check for limited-time flavors, holidays specials, or preorder events
Set a treat budget if you’re shopping with kids
Bring a reusable bag or box if buying in bulk

*Note: Each shop may offer different experiences—check social media for updates.*

How to Get Started

Most shops accept walk-ins! For custom orders, pre-ordering is best. Ask about gift boxes or subscription options.

Other Helpful Info

Visits usually take 10–30 minutes, unless you're sitting down to enjoy
Weekends can be busier—plan ahead for quicker service
Seasonal or limited-edition donuts often rotate monthly
Some locations offer donut decorating kits or workshops
Gift cards, boxes, and party platters are often available

*Note: Features, pricing, and offerings vary by donut shop. Always check ahead.*

Contact Information

Address

35523 Vine St

Eastlake, Ohio 44095

Hours

Monday 3AM-9PM
Tuesday 3AM-9PM
Wednesday 3AM-9PM
Thursday 3AM-9PM
Friday 4AM-11PM
Saturday 3:30AM-12AM
Sunday 9AM-9PM

Customer Reviews

Always fresh and always plenty of donuts to choose from. Best of the best. Coffee is pretty good too ?? ??

i go here all the time and recently it?s always been a hit or miss if they completely destroy the pizza or not, how do you give someone this and think it?s ok?

Maybe it's nostalgia because I grew up on Biagio's, but imo no other donut compares. The sweet flavor. The soft texture. Exquisite ?? Any other donut tastes dry to me in comparison.

Attentive, kind staff. Good donuts. Cash only. I always stop in when I'm in the area. I still remember donuts and pizza with grandma and grandpa in the 80's & 90's. Glad they're still around! The only downside is they don't take credit card. But I get that, too.

These are some of the very best donuts I have eaten in the last 59 years, 43 states and 11 countries. I?ve only found 1 place (Starlight Donuts of Barstow, CA ) that has donuts that can compare to these. If you are in the area, grab ?em!!

Good donuts used to be 5 stars back in the good old days but still good just gotta bring back some fan favorite donuts and be a little cleaner on the inside and the back work food prep area.

One of the best donuts in Cleveland and is ranked 29th in United States! Wow, the donuts are large in portions and the stuffing is so delicious. They have a great variety to choose from. Would definitely recommend this donut shop and is a must try place !

Biagio's Donut Shop & Pizzeria is an absolute must stop for anyone in the Eastlake OH area or anyone driving up highway 90 looking for quite possibly the best donuts on earth. This no frills shop offers a great selection of Paczki's which are essentially large format donuts filled with a variety of jelly's, jams, custards and creams coated with powdered sugar. They are dense but delicious, fresh and oh so tasty. One Paczki probably accounts for anyone's daily caloric quota but don't let that stop you with

I got a 6 cut pizza & half a dozen donuts. The workers were super friendly and the donuts were amazing. They have a wide range of flavors from plain sugar to apple jelly filled. Definitely the best in ohio

My family of 6 and I ordered 2 large pizzas and a dozen donuts. The total was $45 cash and we couldn't be happier. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza with extra cheese and a large mushroom and sausage pizza with extra cheese, honestly I now understand why they're ranked 29th in the nation for pizza and donuts! Outstanding flavors. Great pies! The place was clean and the staff are friendly! We loved it so much, we went back for the same order a few days later.

i got some glazed donuts and theres no holes anymore, so the whole bottom was unglazed. why couldnt you just keep making donuts like before with holes? Very disappointing, not as good as they used to be.

These are the best donuts you will ever have! My family and I have been going here for years! The staff is sweet and so are the people there you'll meet. ?? pictured are 2 pumpkin cake donuts (left), 2 chocolate frosted donuts with sprinkles (bottom), and the maple frosted logs with cream (top right)- I almost never pass up on a maple when I see it! ?? ?? A dollar a donut! A fantastic treat! ??

Hand down the best donuts around with a great selection too. Dunkin' doesn't compare. Just keep in mind if you go here you'll be heading back soon..

Overall, the only reason why this is 4 stars is due to them not accepting Debit or Credit cards. The do have an ATM 2.00 surcharge bringing the bakers dozen of donuts to 18.00 total charge! Isn?t a bad deal, just a bummer! Donuts were delicious, had many different font options!

Eastlake is booming. The corner of Vine and SOM is hardly recognizable these days. It's a good thing. It's a better thing that it retains blasts from the past, that keeps the feeling of "HOME." THAT is Biagio's. Great doughnuts, pizza, smiles. Thanks Eastlake, for keeping Biagio's Alive!

I am very sad to write this review. Biagios has the best doughnuts hands down. I ordered three dozen doughnuts for a School function. Many of my co-workers are Biagios fans. I called a day and a half ahead of time in the morning and arranged for pickup around 5pm. The employee taking my order was wonderful. My husband arrived at 4:55 and was told the order was not ready. Three employees proceeded to throw doughnuts into boxes and threw them on the counter. My husband asked if the order was correct and

Biagio's is Biagio...enough said. Best donuts in Ohio! Got a dozen to bring to work for the crew and they all loved them. You can never go wrong with their donuts!!!

It sucks when you expect a business to be consistent. I just found out they sold pizza. The first one I got was delicious and cheesy. I returned for a second time to a burnt pizza. You would expect a business to want to only push out the best products but no, they chose the cheap way, sell the burnt pizza and let the customer discover their dreams have been shattered once they've gotten home washed their hands and gotten ready to eat an amazing slice only to be met by a dry burnt pizza.......I was highly di

Definitely the best donut shop in Lake County. To be honest, I have never had a better donut anywhere. This place is a local favorite and if you are from out of town it is a must try! I love their chocolate sprinkled donuts ??

Always have loved biagios but tonight I just picked up a dozen donuts and as i was eating one i found bugs inside , called and they said they have a known bug issue ?can?t seem to get rid of them?. Don?t go there.

Donuts fresh and delicious even at 6 o'clock in the evening. Appreciated the patience of the nice lady working the counter because of my indecisiveness...so many donuts to choose from, lol.

Best pizza for the price! The cheese is one of the tastiest cheeses I've ever experienced on a pizza! Not to mention they are open 24 hours so you're able to pick up some pizzas at 3am if you're craving one! Then theres the doughnuts. Baked fresh, numerous options, all flavors and great prices! Nothing like ordering 2 cheese pizzas and a bakers dozen after a night of drinks! Service is 5 star and fast! Plenty of parking and cozy atmosphere!

OMG just had the best Biagios supreme pizza EVER had the right amount of toppings ( Biagio my have rolled over) in 50+ years and cooked perfect as usual Donuts are also the best anywhere don't care what anyone says

I don't know...they just don't taste the same as I remember about 4 years ago. Last time I had them they reminded me of those old world donuts from my childhood with a little bit of crisp on the edges!

I have been going to this donut shop since I was a kid -- now I'm taking my kids there to get some of the tastiest donuts this side of the Mississippi! Highly recommned.

What can a say about this place that everyone hasn?t said already? Truly an amazing place. I?ve been going here since I was a kid and I just turned 30. This was the spot every Friday when I was a kid. We would get Blockbuster movies then go here for pizza and donuts as the weekly tradition. Thank you Biagio?s for being the best place ever for my childhood now adulthood!!

Fine Donuts, coffee, ice cream and Pizza! Friendly service tied to a very neighborly atmosphere. Nice place to sit and eat a donut or 5 with coffee or take out a dozen donuts for the road. Most of time, the carry out never makes it home.

Such an awesome bakery but they have coffee, donuts, and pizza. Nothing else. I went in there to see if I could get some fresh bread rolls but they don't make them. Still though, this place is the best for donuts and pizza. I'm from South Jersey where there are lots of hole in the wall stores and there's hardly any here in Northeast Ohio so I was glad I found this place. Makes me feel right at home.

This is simply the best place to get donuts. Old school place with excellent quality of food and the type of service you don?t find these days. My kids love these donuts as well. I suggest everyone try it out as you won?t be disappointed!!! Thank you to everyone there for always making me feel welcomed

Biagios is your staple donut bakery. It is a local favorite and run by amazing people. If you're looking for an old school donut shop with a family feel, this is definitely a must stop location, but get there early their donuts go quick!

I always visit this yummy donut shop when visiting my old stomping grounds. Tasty! Prompt, friendly service. A must try for everyone who loves donuts! I prefer the cream filled and raspberry filled donuts.

The best donuts I?ve ever had! I?m not sure how it is that I?m just tasting these awesome donuts, but I?m glad I am now in the know! The prices are crazy cheap!

At one time, they had the best donuts, but now they are ok

Best donuts in north east Ohio I?m a west sider and I make the 45 minute drive for these donuts!

I love the donuts here but I believe this business is on a downward spiral. There is a huge sign on the door that says they have new hours and are open at 3:30 am, but for the third time now, I have shown up at 3:30 to find the store closed. This really upsets me, if you?re not gonna be open why post new hours??? And I also received donuts that were not cooked all the way through. I?m sorry to say this, but I think I?m going to have to find a new place for donuts that?s a bit more reliable with their schedu

Best donuts around! Old time donut shop! Also if you get a dozen it?s a bakers dozen so it?s 13!

The best donuts in the Cleveland area! I drove 25 min to get there. Totally worth it every time!

It?s been awhile since I had been here. For some reason I really wanted some good donuts one day. So, since it was on my way home after working overnight, I decided to stop by and grab a couple donuts. I was very underwhelmed and a bit disappointed. The donuts didn?t taste stale but for getting there at 7:30 am they did not taste as fresh as I was expecting. I would rate as just ok.

Best donuts ANYWHERE?haven?t had any that even come close! I?m a 60 yr old retired police officer, so I guess THAT makes me a donut expert, and my age gives me a lot of donut experience. Simply the best, and still reasonably priced!

I'm so glad my favorite donut shop is back to its full menu! ?? It feels like forever since I've had their maple frosted cinnamon roll. Nothing beats a fresh, homemade donut. ?? #SupportLocal #DonutLover ??

Best donuts in town. Stay soft for daysss

The best donuts and pizza I have ever had!!!

2.5 would be a better score. Donuts were fresh for sure. Glazed more on the light side. Workers not too friendly. More like get ur donuts & get out Lol. Hope they hire more welcoming staff in the future.

Let me start with so you know CASH ONLY. They are a small family owned business and that?s just how it has always been even since I was a little kid? NOW Their donuts are out of this world incredible. There?s normally only one person behind the counter and she is fast as she can be even with a nice hefty line. You can?t really compare their donuts to anything you just have to try them and you?ll understand ???? 2 dozen every time. There are no hole cut outs but?.You literally get more doughnut so honestly

Love Biagio's! Went on Fat Tuesday to buy a dozen delicious paczki. They kept the line moving fast! they were delicious!

We got pizzas and a dozen donuts. Absolutely nothing was less than satisfying and delicious. Just keep in mind they're cash only

Always the best! Don't bother getting doughnuts anywhere else.

Favorite since childhood! Freshest donuts around!!

I?m very disappointed, ever since the owner posed away they have went down hill. They stopped making cinnamon roll donuts for at least a year do to lack of bakers. Today I went in to get a dozen and also got three cinnamon rolls on the side, just to find out it was 27$!!!!!!! That is utterly ridiculous!! I almost walked out! Not to mention cinnamon roll donuts are no longer part of a dozen it will cost you extra to get those! Also they stopped putting holes in the or what was the original glaze donuts. No

This place used to be much much better. Should have knew it wasn?t gonna be the same when we walked in.Had gotten about half a dozen glazed which now have no holes. And raspberry filled. Both the doughnuts and the entire store stunk of stink bugs.. ended up throwing them away when we got home. Hope no one else runs into this issue.

Very delicious donut and pastry items and nice staff.

Great donuts support locally owned business

I don?t know how anyone dislikes this place, the doughnuts are the best, you can?t beat them.

They should add more variety. Like vanilla frosted or strawberry frosted since the rainbow sprinkle & chocolate sprinkle both have chocolate frosting. Every time I go in there?s only a few options to choose from. Amazing donuts just wish there were more variety to choose from frosting wise.

Found ourselves on the East side one morning and wanted donuts! Have heard rave reviews about this place so we made our way there. Glazed were the absolute best I've ever had and the chocolate covered strawberry was delicious - nothing I've ever seen before! They use their glazed donuts as a bun for burgers and I'd be willing to try that!!

Best donuts in North East ohio!

Always Great Service! Fresh, hot coffee, wide variety of doughnuts and other mouth watering pastries! Affordable, yet worth every cent!

THE ABSOLUTE BEST DOUGHNUTS IN THE WORLD!!! Their Pizza is also Top-Notch!!! Visit & see for yourself... YOU WILL NOT BE SORRY!!

Great donuts. Dozen for 16$.

Came back to visit friends. First time since 2019 I was at Biagio's. I grew up on them! I was surprised when I pulled in the parking lot only to find 2 cars. When I walked in the cases were full. I ordered a dozen, no more bakers dozen :( !The donuts were NOT the same!! First the had NO HOLES. They were dry. Sadly another fine example of the next generation taking over the business and destroying everything their parents built!

After over 10 years of eating this once delicious food, I stopped in while in town and ordered a large Pizza and some donuts at about 4:15PM on a Friday. After getting back home to eat a half hour later I was mildly disappointe to find that the Pizza that I so remember and looked forward to was no where near the same or as good as I remember, but was still ok and adequate compared to most places I go to recently. Also 2 of the Donuts were hardened, and not fresh and fluffy. I dont ever remember going there

Staff was accommodating and the donuts were perfect on this chilly morning ??

Same place it's been for years, donuts were fresh. Counter help is friendly. I wish they would make the glazed with the different flavor jellies in the center

Hands down the BEST donuts in Northeast Ohio!! My office gets these 2-3 times a week and everyone swarms the boxes. Better be quick to get one...?? Want to try their Pizza soon!

Great place, and even better donuts.

Best donuts I ever had. Whenever I'm near Lake county, I make a detour for my donut addiction.

Still the best doughnuts you can find in Cleveland. Always fresh and delicious. Keep in mind they only accept cash; however, there is an ATM.

How are people giving this place 4 & 5 star reviews? Have you never had a decent donut? The donuts here look like they were made by kindergarteners with vision problems. Raised glazed donuts with no hole and no filling? Raised glazed with no hole and unmelted chocolate smeared on top that looked like they threw the chocolate at the donut from 5 feet away. Cake donuts so dry that they HAD to be days old. If you truly think these donuts are good, you have to get out more...

Always fresh and always great customer service! My family has been going there for many years and I will continue to support this local business. The key is to know what times to go to ensure the greatest selection of scrumptious donuts. I will choose Biagio?s over Dunkin? everyday day of the week and twice on Sunday.

It was so delicious and the price is too good. Thanks to my co-worker Vincent who recommend this to me and to my husband!

Not sure why the hype! Husband surprised me this morning and snuck out to buy donuts which included my favorite cruller donut. We heard so many good things about this place. The assorted donuts tasted day old at 6:45am! Giant Eagle is better in my opinion.

Great donuts but remember they only accept cash. Since there is a lot of deep frying, anticipate coming out smelling like a greasy kitchen but the donuts are worth it.

Amazing and best donuts in the area with lots of options available! A must see and stop when in Cleveland. I?ve seen the reviews and had to try it myself, and they did not disappoint.

First time going here because I actually didn't know they were so close to me. I always see a lot of people with these boxes of doughnuts. I tried an assortment them. Everything was fresh. The customer service was excellent! I'll definitely be coming back. I'll pass right by Dunkin Doughnuts to get here in the future.

After being disappointed a couple of times and showing up in the morning only to find a limited selection. I decided to take some people's advice and go in the afternoon. I showed up at 130 and the selection was excellent. The family was definitely happy and man were those donuts good today. ??

We found this place because it was listed in an article as having some of the best donuts. We went on a Sunday one hour after they opened. There were only 4 donut options. I got the cruller with the custard. It was horrid. It was clearly days old and cold from being stored. It simply crumbled and couldn't even contain the custard from the moment I touched it. The place floors were absolutely filthy, I just don't get it. Maybe they open on Sundays to get rid of their old inventory. Unfortunately I will never

I've been earing Biagios since I was a little girl. The best doughnuts ever, but when I got doughnuts 2 days ago I realized there were no holes in them...weird. still love them

No Belts Allowed ! ! EXCELLENT EVERYTHING? Exceptional Customer Service, Delicious Pizza, Pillow Soft Baptized in Glaze Donuts, Custom made to taste Cappuccino at an amazing price. #LifeChangingExperience

Some of the best doughnuts I've had! The maple icing is perfect, tons of selection, everything the wife and I got will be bought on our next trip again!

Great donuts! unfortunately, they have not yet learned the demand for the product to consumer ratio. If you're not there super early in the morning your getting the very last few they have which is not even worth the trip to their place unless you live close by.

We have been going there for a long time now, but recently we noticed the cream filled dounuts have very little cream filling. Please don't skimp on the cream! We love your donuts and it's hard to find good ones in this area. What happened?

Came here for years before I moved away and it was AMAZING. Now every time I'm in town the selection is very small or the ice cream machine is "broken". I don't usually leave negative reviews for places but the worker was extremely rude this time so here we are. Edit: had to change it to 2 stars cause the donuts are just that good

This has been my favorite local mom and pop shop since I was a child! Been coming here for years and I LOVE the donuts! Best around, great prices, and I tell all my friends about it if they are not from the area. Sometimes lines are long but move relatively quickly. Cash only so be prepared to bring cash and leave with tasty donuts! :)

Not a place to dine in anymore since COVID but the doughnuts are still delicious. I get a dozen every time I visit Ohio. Just miss the cinnamon rolls

Biagio's is a gem in Northeast Ohio. Come here, bring cash, and order 1 of everything ??

My first time there. It was about 9:30a. My favorite donut is chocolate covered glazed. I got 2 of them. I was very happy. I will be returning. Great service. Price ok. This was two weeks ago.

Morning donuts taste like they're from the previos evening.

Maybe the pizza is better than the donuts. I went shortly after they opened on November 7, 2022. We bought a dozen for a variety of donuts to try. They all tasted pretty similar with the exception of there filling. Maybe they use the same dough, I'm not sure.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I find donut shops near me?

Simply enter your zipcode, city, or browse the list of states and cities. We'll instantly show you the best-rated donut spots around—classic bakeries, trendy cafes, and hidden gems alike.

Are all the donut shops listed verified?

Yes! Every listing is reviewed for accuracy. We prioritize shops with real customer ratings, up-to-date menus, and consistent service.

Can I search by flavor or dietary preference?

Absolutely. Filter by popular flavors (like maple, custard, or vegan chocolate), or search for shops offering gluten-free, keto-friendly, or dairy-free options.

Do these shops offer delivery or pre-orders?

Many do! Listings include details on delivery partners, online ordering, and whether you can reserve boxes for pickup—perfect for gifts or events.

I want to send donuts as a gift. Can I do that here?

Sorry, but we don't support this yet! But we are considering adding this option!

What are “limited-time” or seasonal flavors?

These are exclusive donuts offered for holidays or specific times of year—like pumpkin spice in the fall or strawberry shortcake in summer. Check back often—they go fast!

Is this just for big cities?

Not at all. We’re expanding constantly, including small towns, roadside bakeries, and regional favorites. Sweetness knows no bounds.

What if my favorite donut shop isn’t listed?

Let us know! You can suggest a shop directly from our site. We’ll check it out and add it if it meets our standards for quality and service.